Andrew McCutchen farewell post sums up all that is wrong with the Pirates

When the Pittsburgh Pirates finally acknowledged Andrew McCutchen leaving town, the message was polished, sentimental and — depending on how you read it — painfully hollow.

“Famalee Forever... A simple thank you isn’t enough, but for now, best of luck in Texas, Cutch.”

That was the farewell posted on social media the day McCutchen’s minor-league deal with the Texas Rangers became official.

On the surface, it looked like a classy send-off. The graphic was clean. The tone was warm. The familiar “Famalee” slogan invoked the bond between the franchise and its most beloved modern star.

But that message — intentionally or not — summed up everything that continues to frustrate Pirates fans about the organization.

Because the problem wasn’t the goodbye. It was everything that happened before it.

Pirates' farewell message to Andrew McCutchen is too little, too late

For months, the Pirates let McCutchen twist in the wind. The 2013 National League MVP, the face of the franchise’s last playoff era, made it clear he wanted to return. He had spent the previous three seasons back in Pittsburgh helping bridge the gap between the rebuild and the next generation.

He wasn’t demanding a massive contract or chasing personal accolades. He simply wanted to finish where his career began.

Instead, the Pirates stalled. They explored other options. They hesitated. They left one of the most important players in franchise history waiting while the offseason dragged on.

Then, they pivoted and signed Marcell Ozuna. And just like that, the door closed. Only after McCutchen found a new opportunity in Texas did the Pirates suddenly remember how much he meant to the organization.

The Pirates have spent years leaning on the word “Famalee.” It’s a slogan that dates back to the1979 World Series team. Back then, the word meant something. It represented a roster that believed in each other, a clubhouse that played with joy, and a fan base that finally felt reconnected with its team.

But when the Pirates posted “Famalee Forever” to say goodbye to McCutchen, the phrase felt less like a principle and more like a marketing line. Because if “Famalee” actually meant what the organization claims it does, McCutchen never would have been put in that position to begin with.

You don’t let the most beloved player of a generation linger without clarity. You don’t leave the emotional leader of your clubhouse waiting while you explore other options. And you certainly don’t thank him only after he’s forced to move on.

The farewell graphic itself wasn’t offensive. If anything, it was exactly what you would expect from a professional sports team. But that’s precisely the problem. For a player who carried the franchise through its most meaningful modern moments — from the 2013 Wild Card game to the rebirth of baseball in Pittsburgh — the Pirates’ final message felt routine. Safe. Corporate.

“A simple thank you isn’t enough,” the team wrote. And ironically, that may be the truest line they’ve posted all winter.

Because the Pirates didn’t just fail to say enough. They waited too long to say anything at all.