Kevin Goldstein on New Pirates: Bowker, Lambo, and McDonald

Kevin Goldstein.  Baseball Prospectus. Goldstein takes a purely pessimisitic look at some of the Pirates added at the trade deadline.   

Pirates: Here we go again

Like the Royals, the Pirates had little to give away and thus got little in return. Although some young talent is finally creating excitement in Pittsburgh, it’s doubtful that anybody who was added to the system this past weekend will make a real difference in the Pirates’ chances at their first winning season since 1992. In fact, most of these players already appear to be like current or recently failed Pirates if one looks at them with a critical eye, which is hard not to do when it comes to baseball in Pittsburgh. Here’s the purely pessimistic first reaction on all four players picked up at the deadline.

John Bowker: 27-year-old bat-only player who has never proved himself in the big leagues and is limited to first base, just like Jeff Clement.

Pedro Ciriaco, SS: Provides slightly better defense than Ronny Cedeno but even worse bat.

Andrew Lambo, OF: Once-promising hitter has stalled at the upper levels, pretty much the next Brandon Moss.

James McDonald, RHP: Potential back-end starter similar to the pitchers the Pirates have filled their entire rotation with for years.

Next Pirates Game View full schedule »
Friday, Aug 2929 Aug7:05Cincinnati RedsBuy Tickets

Tags: Pirates Blog Pittsburgh Pirates

  • Catch

    This purely pessimistic reaction looks strangely like the PBC Blog reaction.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Kevin Goldstein on New Pirates: Bowker, Lambo, and McDonald | Rum Bunter | A Pittsburgh Pirates Blog --

  • BigB23

    lol wow thats a pathetic review..”Lambo a once promising hitter” haha hes 22 years old in AA what the hell are you talking about? and James McDonald was a top prospect and has really good stuff better than Duke Maholm Ohlendorf and pretty much anyone else they had for awhile…do ppl a favor Goldstein and dont even post anything like this when its complete bullshit and just hate on your behalf. Thanks