Former Showalter Bench Coach, Carlos Tosca Seems A Longshot However…


The Atlanta Braves made Carlos Tosca their bench coach a couple of days ago.  Today, he was in Pittsburgh as the 7th interview candidate for the job of Pirates manager. 

He would seem to be a longshot, but we dug up a few things on Tosca that at least make him interesting.  I’m curious with all of his time (he coached an 18-year old Don Mattingly) and connections in the game if Tosca could field an interesting team of coaches?

Fact one:  Tosca was fired by the Blue Jays.  (ESPN) Tosca, 50, was the fifth native of Cuba to manage in the major leagues. He had been the team’s third-base coach before becoming the sixth major league manager without any playing experience. He finished with a 189-191 record in a little more than two seasons with the Jays.  Also from the same story, check out this quote:

“We have six or seven weeks left in the season and the team showed signs of not playing hard,” Toronto general manager J.P. Ricciardi

Interesting fact two:   John Gibbons was his replacement.  Gibbons was also interviewed for the Pirates skipper post this week.

Most interesting fact:  Tosca was a bench coach for Buck Showalter who worked with Tosca in the Gulf Coast League had this to say about him:

“Carlos was somebody who was good at everything, no job was beneath him. And he’d outwork you.”–Buck Showalter

A good article that included Showalter’s quote discussed Tosca as a baseball lifer said this:  After Tosca spent 17 years as a minor-league manager, racking up 12 winning seasons (932-827), Showalter brought him to the bigs as his bench coach, where “Six-Gun Tosca” derived the reputation of being a straight-shooter and baseball savvy.

One more link that I liked was this:

Q. You spent 17 seasons as a minor league manager and won 932 games before getting your first shot in the big leagues in 1998. How did you finally get that break?

A. Buck Showalter was still a player in the Yankees system when I first met him. Then shortly after that he retired and became a coach. We had an opportunity then to work together in extended Spring Training. I moved on from the Yankees, and Buck eventually became their major league manager. I’d run into him every once in a while and he’d say, “I’m trying to get you on the staff.” I thought, yeah, right. Then, when he got the job in Arizona he called and offered me the position as his bench coach. Buck’s got a tremendous ability to recognize talent and put a team together. We lost 97 games in 1998, but we went on to win 100 games the very next season. It was quite a thrill to be able to see that come to fruition.

Do you think Tosca could work his magic with the Bucs?  105 losses to 90 wins?  Now that would be a miracle. 


St. Pete Times had this chart too.  We adjusted a little bit….Managers who didn’t play pro ball and one jackass:

Ed Barrow 1903-04 Detroit, 1918-20 Boston 310-320

Hugo Bezdek 1917-19 Pittsburgh 166-187

Judge Fuchs 1929 Boston Braves 56-98

Ted Turner 1977 Atlanta 0-1

John Boles 1996, 99-2001 Florida 205-241

Carlos Tosca 2002-04 Toronto 191-191

Dave Trembley 2007-present, Baltimore 72-86

Topics: Carlos Tosca, Pirates Blog, Pittsburgh Pirates

Want more from Rum Bunter?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.

TEAMFeed More Pirates news from the Fansided Network

Hot on the Web From