No Pedro Alvarez In the Home Run Derby? Seriously David Wright?


Here’s another story for all my readers. I’m on my way to PNC Park tonight. I decide to check my phone – at a red light, of course – and scroll through my Twitter timeline in the brief period. I see a lot of angry Pirate fans, and wonder why everyone is furious. I get to PNC, start my short walk to the greatest ballpark in America, and continue to read my Twitter timeline, trying to figure out why all these Pirate fans are angry.

I come across a tweet: Bryce Harper over Alvarez for the Home Run Derby? Are you kidding me?

I shortly realize that the Home Run Derby participants were released, and by the obviousness of that tweet, assume my favorite player Pedro Alvarez wasn’t picked. Man, was I an angry fan walking into PNC Park after reading the four participants. I go through the entrance, give a sarcastic laugh as I get metal-detected by PNC Park security (what a joke that is), and head for my seats.

I sit down at my seats, and like almost any other Pirate fan would, begin to fire away at Twitter my thoughts on the picks.

June 30, 2013; New York, NY, USA; New York Mets third baseman David Wright (5) in the dugout against the Washington Nationals at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: William Perlman/The Star-Ledger via USA TODAY Sports

David Wright as the captain? Seriously? Okay, I get it. The game is played at Citi Field. There should always be a hometown representative. Do I agree with that? No. Kind of like how I laugh at the whole “there should always be a hometown representative” when I think about how Justin Upton wasn’t a captain, let alone a participant, when the Derby was held at Chase Field in 2011. You know, the same year that Upton finished the season fourth in MVP voting and hit 31 homers.

In my opinion, Wright shouldn’t be in the Derby. Whether he’s a hometown player or not, I’m a firm believer in sending the four best power hitters in the National League out there and letting them put on a show. I quickly got over the fact that Wright was in it, but then started to get angry again when I looked at his picks.

Michael Cuddyer. Bryce Harper. Carlos Gonzalez.

Cuddyer in the Home Run Derby? Come on now. Wright said his main reason for picking Cuddyer was that they grew up together and that the two are very good friends. Are you kidding me? That’s cute, David. Hang out with him the whole break then, grab a beer with him after the game/derby, sit with him in dugout. Do something – ANYTHING – other than pick him for the Home Run Derby when there are a dozen other people around the National League who are more deserving.

He’s been in the league since 2001, and has one season with over thirty homers. When I think of Cuddyer, I think about a solid ballplayer. A respectable average, decent amount of runs driven in, average amount of home runs, and a guy who brings versatility, being able to play at a few different positions around the field. I don’t think of Cuddyer as a home run hitter, especially not Home Run Derby material. He’s putting together a nice season at the age of 34, and is deserving of a spot in the All-Star game, but did he earn his ticket to the Home Run Derby? Absolutely not.

May 16, 2013; San Diego, CA, USA; Washington Nationals left fielder Bryce Harper (34) on the bench prior to the game against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Christopher Hanewinckel-USA TODAY Sports

Next, we look at Harper. Unlike a lot of fans around the world of baseball, I can’t stand Harper. He’s a great player, I’ll give him that, but I get extremely annoyed when I look at his meltdowns on the field and cockiness he brings into the league as a 20-year old. Harper is starting in the All-Star game that takes place Tuesday night. I was already angry about that when I found that news out on Saturday afternoon, and when I saw that he will be in the Derby, I couldn’t help but laugh.

“But Drew! He hit a 500-foot home run and was on the cover of Sports Illustrated as a 16-year old! What did you do when you were sixteen years old?” Give me a break. He’s a phenom, and turning into one of the faces of the MLB, but this guy shouldn’t be in the Derby.

He’s missed a good bit of the season due to injuries, and is holding a mediocre average at .260. He’s hit 13 homers, the same amount as the “captain,” David Wright. He’s driven in 29 runs. The fan-vote will of course get him into every All-Star game the next ten years, and if it weren’t for a absurd voting system that the MLB uses, there’s no way Harper would be in the All-Star game, let alone the Home Run Derby.

Does he deserve to be an All-Star? No. Does he deserve to start the All-Star game in centerfield? No. Does he deserve to be in the Home Run Derby? No.

Gonzalez is deserving of his nod at the Home Run Derby. His 24 home runs rank him at the top of National League in that department. Congratulations, David, you got one right.

As for Alvarez, I didn’t think there was any question he belonged in the Derby. I wrote an article that was posted on Monday about how Pedro Alvarez deserved a standing ovation at PNC Park. In that article, I included this.

He’s going to be playing at Citi Field on Tuesday, and if the MLB were smart, they would have him hitting in the Home Run Derby on Monday night. He should, without a doubt, be one of the four NL representatives, but that’s another opinion for another time.

Well here’s my opinion on that which was, as promised, for another time.

The man has 22 home runs, and is becoming known around the league for how far some of them travel. Watching Alvarez turn on a pitch and send it out of PNC Park has to be one of the best things to watch in the Major Leagues. If he were to have been picked as a Home Run Derby participant, he would have done the best out of the National League representatives. He would have had a serious case of winning the whole thing.

Alvarez wasn’t the only one to get snubbed out of this. Paul Goldschmidt, possibly the MVP of the National League thus far, has hit 21 homers, and will not be in it. Dominic Brown, another player making a real name for himself this season in the MLB, has 23 homers, and he had a serious chance of making it.

Wright has always been my favorite non-Pirate, and I’m serious when I say that. Ever since he came to PNC Park in 2006 and put on a show in the Home Run Derby – one that he deserved to make – he’s been my favorite player. I still like the guy, but he’s definitely lost some of my respect after his picks. He’s coming to PNC Park this weekend for a 3-game series, and I, along with the rest of Pirate Nation, are going to boo him until he can’t take it anymore.

You know what’s going to be awesome though? When Alvarez hits a couple of home runs this weekend and the crowd goes crazy as he runs past Wright, who will be kicking dirt and looking at the ground, as he ponders his decision of passing up on picking Alvarez to the Home Run Derby.

Even 2012 Cy Young winner, and former teammate of Pedro Alvarez at the University of Vanderbilt, David Price, agrees with me on this one.

A.J. Burnett is one of the main leaders of this Pirates team, and he displayed that with this tweet Monday afternoon.

Next Pirates Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Aug 2020 Aug7:05Atlanta BravesBuy Tickets

Tags: Pittsburgh Pirates

  • Stargell_Stars

    Nice job, Wright, picking a 34 year old who benefits greatly from Coors field and a guy who’s been injured half the year. For the first time ever I will be rooting for the AL in the Derby. Hope your buddy hits 0 HR and gets KO’d in the first round. Go EL TORO!!!

  • mb

    David Wright shouldn’t be in the HR Derby either let alone picking at least two other players that are less deserving to participate. He should have been a true leader and picked the top HR hitters on his squad, not choosing someone cause they’ve been buddies for a long time. Just another example of typical injustice of the all star game.

  • poop

    dom brown

  • brendan

    wow no pedro but micheal cuddyer just because wright was buddies with him that’s a complete joke the league needs to do something about that and no dominic brown either wow hope the al wins at least cano picked god players to be in the derby the only good player for the nl in the derby is carlos gonzalez and I cant wait to see pedro crush some homers against david wright and the mets

  • brendan

    the league shouldn’t even let the captains pick the players because then it becomes about hanging out with your buddies and not hurting your buddies feelings becvause you don’t pick them in the home run derby. I hope the league takes a look at this and lets pedro alvarez and dominic brown both be in it because then I will actually watch it. Just a complete joke I am furious right now.

  • brendan

    and I also heard that at first david wright wasn’t even supposed to be the captain it was supposed to be matt kemp for the dodgers but he got hurt so pedro alvarez and dominic brown would both be in it probably if kemp was the captain it wouldn’t be about picking your buddies just really disappointed. pedro and brown and gonzlaez all earned it harper and cuddyer didn’t harper has been hurt most of the year and cuddyer is just an average solid ballplayer. hopefully the league could find a way to let pedro and dom brown participate cuz both of those guys are boneified sluggers in the league and they deserve to be there

  • Alan Davidson

    wonder if AJ will buzz the tower on him

  • metsman

    I just read some tweets and thought I’d come over here to see what Bucs fans were saying. I have tremendous respect for this franchise, love your stadium, and you guys are considered as a whole, a classy and steadfast fan base….BUT

    …. it’s the homerun derby for crying out loud! People barely even watch the thing! next thing you know people will be upset about the selections for the old timers game…and as for people bad mouthing Wright as a selection in the first place, the guy broke the existing record for a single round (at the time) when he was in the derby before. I would love to see this Alveras kid in the Derby, and it’s lame that he wasn’t picked, but I voted for him and Mccutchen to be in the All Star game; the only event of any substance in the whole AS break besides the futures game …people talking about hitting Wright on this board? that’s nuts!

  • akwentoo

    So, how did the Alvarez pick work out? I guess Harper was not a bad selection by the fans who chose him in a poll. I don’t blame wright for picking Cuddyer. He also did better than Alvarez

  • Pingback: Pedro Alvarez Will Compete In Home Run Derby - Rum Bunter - A Pittsburgh Pirates Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and More