Top Five Catchers in Pittsburgh Pirates History

facebooktwitterreddit
Prev
6 of 6
Next
PITTSBURGH, PA – 2003: Catcher Jason Kendall of the Pittsburgh Pirates attempts to throw out a base runner during a Major League Baseball game at PNC Park in 2003 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by George Gojkovich/Getty Images)
PITTSBURGH, PA – 2003: Catcher Jason Kendall of the Pittsburgh Pirates attempts to throw out a base runner during a Major League Baseball game at PNC Park in 2003 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by George Gojkovich/Getty Images) /

Number 1 – Jason Kendall

This one was tough. It really came down to what was more valuable – above average defense with average offense, or above average offense with average defense. But Jason Kendall had a dynamic athletic factor to his game that most catchers do not have, and it really gave him the edge here.

Kendall averaged 20 stolen bases a season between 1997 and 2002. But, overall, Kendall was an all-around great hitter. During his tenure with the Bucs, he batted .306/.387/.416. That also included a 140 total stolen bases, 1.2 base running runs above average, and a 113 wRC+/108 OPS+.

Although he was an awful pitch framer, Kendall was not horrible defensively. He was above average in catching runners trying to steal on him. He also had a 5.5 dWAR in Pittsburgh. Although the stat was created in the last season he was in Pittsburgh, Kendall was still responsible for +31 defensive runs saved, including +19 in his age 34 season. If he was that good defensively at 34-years-old, he couldn’t have been that bad in his prime with the Pirates.

Next. How can Pitching Prospect Braxton Ashcraft Improve in 2020?. dark

During Kendall’s tenure with the Pittsburgh Pirates, the team did not have a single winning season. Due to this, the play of Kendall gave fans something to root for when there was not much else positive about the club.