Reds Plunk Pirates McCutchen--You Really Didn't See It Coming?


Dusty Baker had Andrew McCutchen plunked.  The switch was turned on.  The Reds took over the game.  Seems too easy, doesn’t it?  Look back at how many times the Reds have plunked Cutch.  Typically in the first game of the series, sometimes early in games; it’s a fact–Baker is going to plunk Cutch.

Now, it’s up to the Pirates to retaliate.

When it happened last season, we were pretty upset.  But to not see it coming tonight, the Bucs had to have had blinders on.  Sure, we don’t understand why Sam LeCure wasn’t tossed, but that’s what makes Dusty Baker so genius.  It’s not the first team he has employed this tactic with, but just once, we would like to see the Pirates dictate the action.

The wild thing is how quickly the Reds responded.

And how the Pirates responded.  A few pitches later and the Reds and Bucs were tied in the NL Central.  Sure, Jordy Mercer didn’t help much with that horrid throw.  Yes, Pedro Alvarez didn’t help much. Sure, giving Disco the twitter didn’t help, either.

This isn’t all on Mark Melancon.  (But a pitch or two on the hands was out of the question thanks to Baker’s evil genius.)

This Pittsburgh Pirates team always responds.  We’re waiting.

And one of these series, the Pirates will dictate the action in terms of this bean ball madness.  We’re waiting on that, too.

Here is the article we wrote last season that everyone hated.   After Cutch was plunked by Ardolis Chapman, everyone thought JMac would respond the next day, it didn’t happen.



So, that’s all Pittsburgh Pirates fans got last night? What happened to “Pride, Passion, Pittsburgh Pirates?” We’ve listened to your passionate speeches for a couple of years now, and that’s what we got? Fans got to see you asking crew chief Brian Gorman “Why did you do that?”

What? Gorman threw you out, because you said too much.

Winners dictate. Winners dominate. Winners control their own destiny. You know all of these things. Hell, you preach ‘em everyday.

The Pittsburgh Pirates didn’t dictate anything last night. Specifically, you didn’t dictate anything last night. It really was surprising to us.

You’re a man that says all the right things. You talk the talk. Hell, you were even very candid when you spoke to us in a RumBunter podcast at the start of the season.

We can’t imagine why you chose this city over New York, but we tell you what – we are damn glad you did.

Until last night.

As fans, we deserved more. In the interview we had with you, you made the point that Pittsburgh was a football and hockey city. Last night, we thought you were going to show us what an old-school baseball town was.

It never happened.

Right now, Pittsburgh certainly feels like a baseball city, and come Monday evening it will feel like that again, but a void will still be present among your players and some of your fans. Maybe too much was riding on the game in the Chili City last night.

It was prime time and the club was blacked out. You were blacked out, tossed, gone, sent to the showers. Unreal. The guy that is credited with turning baseball around in this town got tossed from the most meaningful series this franchise has had in twenty years.

What a shame.

Maybe the team knew what the plan was going in. If so, we understand the outcome. Cue the jugglers.

When you spoke in the podcast, you said that the Pittsburgh school systems were off the chart. Obviously, that was important to your family when you made your decision to come to Pittsburgh. If you were to relate that to the ball diamond, isn’t old school baseball important too?

Many people like to point to the fact that you’ve had just one winning season as a manager in the bigs. That season was magical. People called you a player’s manager. So, what was up last night?

Andrew McCutchen is an MVP candidate. You have spoken glowingly about him. Hell, you actually predicted what McCutchen is doing right now. On a daily basis, your prophetic predictions are coming true.

So what happened last night? Why not defend Cutch early, and get it over with? Dictate. Dominate.

When we listened to the podcast again, we found something interesting you said that has great relevance to the game last night.

‘You don’t wait for leadership opportunities.’ Clint Hurdle

A Pirates team in the midst of a playoff run needed leadership last night. Leadership didn’t show. The Bucs are now five and a half games back of the NL Central leading Reds. The Reds are playing like the best team in baseball.

Nothing you did last night changed that fact.

Nothing you did dictated the action.

No wonder your MVP candidate was juggling baseballs on the bench. He struck out twice in an 0-fer-night. Cutch hadn’t struck out twice in a game in two weeks, so that’s on him. But last night was on you. As you said in the podcast, everyone is a better manager than you, so it’s really easy for us to write this and second guess your decision. We get it.

But look it’s not like we are talking about Brian Giles or Jack Wilson anymore. Andrew McCutchen is a star. A star on and off the field. Good Lord, he’s the guy that first thought about having his Dad to pitch to him in the Home Run Derby. When that didn’t work out, he picked his Fort Meade High School Coach Jon Spradlin.

That’s the type of player we are talking about – a guy that thought of his high school coach when he was picked for the Home Run Derby… and you didn’t defend him immediately, Clint?

Is putting the lead base runner of the game that make or break? Wouldn’t it show JMac your utmost confidence in him, too?

We’re curious if you asked McCutchen what he thought about the situation. If Cutch said it’s not that big of a deal, okay… cool, we bet you probably thanked him for his opinion. But then you go out and still take care of business immediately.

Cutch is a guy tearing up this league; he gives you six wins over replacement. A superstar. He took a 101-mph fastball from the hardest throwing left handed pitcher in baseball. And you did nothing to respond to it. Nothing.

The face of the franchise was drilled. The franchise does nothing to defend him. To a nobody like me, that’s pretty jacked.

Sure Brian Gorman made a very questionable decision, but you know what? So did you.

Thank you for your passion,


Next Pirates Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:15at St. Louis CardinalsBuy Tickets

Tags: Pittsburgh Pirates

  • Josh Bresser

    This doesn’t make much sense. It was on a 2-2 count in a fairly tense game. It was also Sam LeCure, who runs his fastball up to 92 on a good day. I’m sure if Dusty wanted to plunk McCutchen, it would have been on a clean count early in the game with Mat Latos and his (potentially) 97 mph heater.

    Although, by all means, I hope they use Jeff Locke and his unexciting fastball to plunk Phillips as retaliation…his OBP has been one of the worst in baseball since the break, so they could use the runner.

    And I’m sure McCutchen, knowing the game, wouldn’t take offense to getting hit by a 2-2 pitch to leadoff an inning . Because a plunk there doesn’t make baseball sense.

  • marcorincon

    All I want to know is why wasn’t Barmes put in to play ss in bottom of 9th? He was put in to play ss in the 10th? ….When the horses are all nearly out of the barn? That’s poor managing and I don’t care if Hurdle wasn’t in the dugout at that time, someone has to know to insert Barmes to ss when you have a 3run lead late in the game!

  • Obsidia

    Yeah, I’m not a fan of “revenge plunking” either. It, to me, does nothing for the game. To my mind, Melancon was ambushed by the Reds. They knew he was vulnerable and went after him. They knew the Pirates would be lax because they had a lead. It was all carefully planned out by “evil genius” Baker. The way to counter this is to “mix it up” a little. Don’t do what you always do. Change things up. Confuse Baker’s mind. And don’t be so grim! Instead, laugh a lot! That would annoy the Reds the most!!!

  • Josh Bresser

    Well, now McCutchen has even said it wasn’t on purpose..