Pittsburgh Pirates Homestand Report Card 7/6 – 7/15

The Pittsburgh Pirates are on fire. The Bucs ended the first half of the 2018 season with a 10-game home stand against three playoff contenders and went 7-3, highlighted by a five-game sweep of the Milwaukee Brewers.

After a “meh” series with the Philadelphia Phillies to start this stretch, in which the Pittsburgh Pirates lost two of three, Pittsburgh won six of its last seven games to roll into the All-Star break playing its best baseball of the season.

Not everything was perfect.

The homestand started with an embarrassing 17-5 loss to Philadelphia, and also featured the continued disappearance of Austin Meadows, which has caused a stir among fans and media. For the most part, however, the Bucs are clicking, and because of that, people shouldn’t be complaining about much.

Here’s a breakdown of how the Pirates starting pitching, relief pitching, and offense performed over this past homestand. Let’s get into it.

Pitching – the good

After the beatdown that started this stretch, the Pirates much-criticized starting rotation stepped up for the rest of the homestand.

Jameson Taillon is finally starting to pitch like the No. 1 that the Bucs need him to be, dominating in both of his outings this homestand Nick Kingham continues to show promise, tossing a gem in Sunday’s finale against the Phillies. Since coming back from injury, Ivan Nova has pitched well, tossing a gem Monday night against the Nationals and following that up with a solid outing against the Brewers in the first end of Saturday’s double header.

This is still a rotation that has a lot of holes, and we don’t know if guys like Kingham, Trevor Williams or Clay Holmes will become consistently good. Over the past two weeks, however, there’s been little to complain about with the starting rotation.

Pitching – the bad

Williams was the starting pitcher of that 17-3 game. Joe Musgrove had a rough fifth inning against the Nationals, and was left in a batter too long against the Brewers Sunday, a decision that should have cost the Pirates the game. Aside from that, the rotation did its job. Hopefully, this group can continue to impress going forward.

B

Offense – the good

Starling Marte has been the furthest thing from a liability recently, and fellow outfielder Gregory Polanco has been raking as well. Josh Bell is starting to come around at the dish, ending a good week with an epic walk off hit Sunday afternoon.

Even role player Jordan Luplow made a big splash with a two home run game in the nightcap of Saturday’s doubleheader. Overall, the Pirates averaged nearly five runs per in this ten game stretch. As I’ve been saying all year, for the Bucs to make the most out of their talent, the bats have to lead the way. Right now, they are doing their part.

More from Rum Bunter

• Pittsburgh Pirates Prospect Stockwatch: Outfielder Tres Gonzalez
• Pittsburgh Pirates Podcast: Rum Bunter Radio Talks Winter Meetings Fallout
• Pittsburgh Pirates: Potential Leadoff Hitters in 2023
• Pittsburgh Pirates: The Rotation is not being Improved
• Pittsburgh Pirates Make Vince Velasquez Signing Official

Offense – the bad

While the success of the outfield has made Meadows’ continuous isolation easier to understand, the way the Pirates have handled the rookie, who is now in Triple-A for the time being, is still frustrating. While Luplow has shown flashes of brilliance, he isn’t better than Meadows. This kid needs at-bats, and Clint Hurdle isn’t giving them to him.

While the organization deserves criticism for how they’ve handled their 2013 first-round draft choice, It’s unfortunate that fans appear to be more upset about Meadows than they are happy about the team winning, but cynicism is nothing new here.

Overall, the offense is doing its part to help the Pirates win, and this lineup has the talent to keep it rolling.

A-

Bullpen – the good

Felipe Vasquez continues to dominate. After a rough patch in May, the Pirates closer hasn’t allowed a run in over a month and has reestablished himself as the anchor of the ‘pen.

Aside from Vasquez, Kyle Crick and Edgar Santana remain solid, as they’ve been all season. Like the starting rotation, the Pirates relief pitching has its question marks. But right now, the relievers are picking up right where the starters are leaving off, and for once, that’s a good thing.

Bullpen – the bad

Michael Feliz still hasn’t figured it out. He’s allowed runs in two of his three appearances since being activated off the DL, and his 1.57 WHIP for the season speaks for itself. More so than other positions, relief pitchers are capable of getting hot at any moment, however, and a stretch of dominance by Feliz would be huge to this young and inconsistent group.

The ‘pen allowed 12 of the 17 runs in that woeful loss to the Phillies, and it would be unfair to single out one person for that train wreck. The next days 3-2 loss was also disappointing, as Santana couldn’t come through after Taillon’s curious removal with a 2-0 lead in the seventh inning.

Aside from the Philly series, however, much like the rest of the team, the bullpen was good and deserves a pat on the back for the time being.

B-