Pittsburgh Pirates home stand report card 7/26 – 8/5

The Pittsburgh Pirates are ready to embark on a three-city, nine-game road trip following a 4-5 homestand

It was an interesting homestand for the Pittsburgh Pirates. On the surface, going 4-5 in games against the lowly Mets and two division rivals in the Cubs and Cardinals seems underwhelming, and it was disappointing to an extent. But this week also featured the most exciting day Pittsburgh baseball has experienced in almost three years, that being the 2018 MLB Trade Deadline.

The Bucs made two splashes, acquiring reliever Keone Kela from the Texas Rangers early Tuesday morning before adding starting pitcher Chris Archer from the Tampa Bay Rays later in the day. Both of these pieces unquestionably make the team better, and now people are starting to believe that the 2018 season may not be a lost cause.

So while the team didn’t do itself any favors over the past nine games on the surface, the front office unquestionably put them in a position to compete both now and in the future.

Here is a breakdown of how the Pirates performed this past homestand, using a “report card” format. Let’s get into it.

Starting pitching – the good

Trevor Williams continues to show that he belongs in a MLB rotation, shoving in both of his starts over the homestand. Jameson Taillon did his job in Tuesday’s 4-3 win over the Cubs, and Ivan Nova showed up in a big win last Friday against the Mets.

The biggest positive from a pitching standpoint this week was the Archer trade. So even if the Pirates rotation didn’t perform well statistically this week, which they did, acquiring Archer would have put this homestand in the “win” column almost regardless of what else happened

Starting pitching – the bad

Nick Kingham left no doubt as to who would get the shaft with Archer coming in after getting shelled in both of his outings. After good Nova showed up against the Mets, bad Nova made his return this past Saturday in a loss to the Cardinals.

Aside from Kingham, every member of the rotation contributed over this past homestand, with Joe Musgrove keeping the Mets at bay in a tough-luck 1-0 loss to the Mets in last Sunday’s series finale. So, overall, it was a good week for Bucco arms even without the Archer trade.

B+

Bullpen – the good

Like the starting rotation with Archer, the ‘pen got better at the deadline with the addition of Kela. Aside from Kela, the Pirates relievers have come into their own over this hot 25-game stretch, and they are becoming a fun unit to watch.

Felipe Vazquez and Kyle Crick are filthy. Richard Rodriguez is a master at stranding baserunners, and Edgar Santana should thrive as more of a short-inning guy with Kela in the fold.

The ‘pen had to come up big on a few occasions, throwing 5.2 innings in this Friday’s win over the Cardinals, and four innings in last Friday’s win over the Mets. After some rough patches in 2018, the bullpen is coming into its own and should become even more enjoyable as the season rolls on.

Bullpen – the bad

Steven Brault pitched himself back to Triple-A, and Alex McRee happened. Those weren’t good things, and it would be nice to see Huntington add a short-inning reliever, preferably a left-handed one, to stabilize things when starters aren’t able to go seven, six or even five innings.

Overall, the bullpen is arguably the most exciting aspect about this team at the moment. Who’d have ever thought that would be the case?

A-

Overall

The most important thing to take from this homestand is that the Pittsburgh Pirates are better then they were when they left Cleveland nearly two weeks ago. As annoying as it was to lose two of three to the Cardinals, the buzz around this team is, well, existent, for the first time in what feels like forever.

As far as wins and losses go, the Pirates didn’t really take a step forward, but they didn’t hurt themselves too much, either. That said, If this club is to make a playoff push, which still seems unlikely, 4-5 stretches won’t cut it. Neither will 5-4 runs, and maybe not even 6-3.

Pittsburgh played average baseball for the first four months of the season, and this past homestand was a good example of that. The acquisitions of Kela and Archer have improved the team and raised expectations, and the two newcomers will need to live up to the hype for the Bucs to make a run.

Even if the Pirates don’t make the playoffs, they made themselves better this week, and that’s something that can’t be argued.

Overall Grade:

B