4 players with options the Pittsburgh Pirates should monitor

The offseason is quickly approaching. At the end of this year's Postseason, teams will soon need to figure out which players on club options they should bring back, let go in free agency, or buy out. The same goes for players weighing their player options. Once these get resolved, the free agent market can further expand.

There are definitely some players the Pittsburgh Pirates should keep an eye on who are currently tied to options. If they reach free agency, they should be on the Pirates' radar as they fill holes and reinforce current weak points. The Pirates should go after these four players if they hit the open market.

Ryan O'Hearn

Ryan O'Hearn was one of the worst hitters in baseball heading into 2023. After a hot start to his career with the Kansas City Royals in 2018, O'Hearn went on to bat just .211/.282/.351 with a .275 wOBA and 68 wRC+ in 901 plate appearances from 2019-2022. The Baltimore Orioles then acquired him for cash, DFA'd him just days after the trade, and despite all of that, O'Hearn put together two very solid seasons for the O's.

O'Hearn has batted .275/.329/.450 with a .334 wOBA and 119 wRC+ since joining the Orioles. He struck out over 26% of the time with the Royals, but has K'd in just 17.5% of his plate appearances with the Orioles. O'Hearn greatly improved his plate discipline from 2023 to 2024, going from a 22.3% strikeout rate from his first year in Baltimore to just 14%, while his walk rate more than doubled, rising from just 4.1% to 9.3%. On top of all that, Hearn has hit for above-average power, with 29 homers over his last 862 plate appearances and a .175 isolated slugging percentage.

O'Hearn's numbers under the hood were also promising. He was above the 80th percentile in each of xwOBA (.352), xBA (.280), and xSLG% (.467). The slugger also saw his chase rate go from the 33rd percentile last year to the 65th percentile, while his whiff rate dropped from 23.3% to just 18.8%.

O'Hearn split his time at first base and designated hitter, with a handful of games in the corner outfield. He is not considered a particularly great defensive first baseman, with -2 outs above average at the position this year, but he did grade out positively last season with +4 OAA. First base is his best position, but he can play an outfield corner when needed.

The only knock on O'Hearn are his platoon splits. He batted .264/.338/.439 with a 123 wRC+ against right-handed pitching, but O'Hearn slashed just .262/.295/.310 with a 75 wRC+ when tasked with facing a southpaw. The Orioles maximized his value against right-handed pitching, as over 90% of his plate appearances came against opposite-handed hurlers. 

Notably, O'Hearn could also benefit from a move away from Camden Yards. In the last two seasons, he has a 91 and 103 wRC+ at home in 2023 and 2024, respectively. Onn the road, he has wRC+ marks of 142 and 134. PNC Park is also considered more hitter friendly for left-handed batters compared to Camden.

O'Hearn has a club option worth $8 million with no buyout. The Orioles have myriad infielders, so they might forgo the club option for a platoon first baseman, even if said platoon first baseman is decent. If O'Hearn hits the free agent market, the Pirates need to jump all over this opportunity.

Phil Maton

The Tampa Bay Rays picked up Phil Maton after he posted a 3.00 ERA fueled by a 27% strikeout rate, a 9.1% walk rate, and 0.82 HR/9 with the Houston Astros in 2023. Maton induced a ton of weak contact with the Astros, with batted balls against him averaging out to an 84.5 MPH exit velocity and 7.2% barrel rate. The Rays were hoping to get more production like that, but things ended up not going as planned.

The veteran reliever posted just a 4.58 ERA, 5.63 FIP, and 1.33 WHIP while in Tampa. His strikeout rate dropped significantly to just 19.7%, while his walk rate rose to 11.8%. Maton became much more home run prone with a 1.58 HR/9 rate. He also induced far less soft contact, with an 87.1 MPH exit velocity and 9.1% barrel rate. 

The Rays decided to move on from Maton, sending him packing to the New York Mets for cash, but this ended up being a great pickup for the Metropolitans. Maton pitched to a 2.51 ERA, 2.57 FIP, and 0.84 WHIP. His strikeout rate returned to his 2023 level, coming in at 26.5%, but his walk rate significantly improved to 5.3%. His strikeout rate isn't the only number that returned closer to his 2023 form, as his exit velocity dropped to 85.1 MPH, and his barrel rate fell to 4.1%. This, in turn, helped him lower his HR/9 to 0.31.

So far in the postseason, Maton has not pitched well for the Mets. He has only logged 2.2 innings, but has allowed four earned runs. Two of the seven hits he has allowed have left the park, and he has struck out a trio of batters to combat just one walk. It is a small sample size that likely will not greatly impact the Mets' decision, but is worth noting nonetheless.

The Mets now hold a $7.75 million team option over Maton. If he pitched like he did with the Mets for the entire year, he'd almost assuredly return for the second season of his contract. But he didn't, and he struggled before getting traded. $7.75 million isn't an inexpensive option, considering the season Maton is coming off of. If he does hit the open market, he is a reliever who could help bolster the Pirates' bullpen.

Andrew Chafin

If the Mets' decision over Maton is up in the air because of how strong his ending to the season was, then Chafin's team option is up in the air because of how poorly he ended 2024. Chafin signed with the Detroit Tigers last offseason after splitting 2023 with the Arizona Diamondbacks and Milwaukee Brewers, and he was a quality left-handed bullpen arm for the Tigs to start the year. 

He owned a 3.16 ERA, 2.55 FIP, and 1.38 WHIP heading into the trade deadline. Chafin struck out over 30% of his opponents with a 30.9% K%, and only allowed home runs at an 0.49-per-9 rate. His 9.9% walk rate wasn't great, but overall, he had a strong season up to this particular breaking point. Considering he only allowed a 6.3% barrel rate but a .355 batting average on balls in play, Chafin had the potential to be even better.

But the second half of the season did not go as planned. Chafin was traded to the Texas Rangers, but fell apart down the stretch. He pitched 19.1 more innings, working to the tune of a 4.19 ERA, 5.33 FIP, and 1.66 WHIP. His strikeout rate fell to 23.8%, while his HR/9 rose to 1.40. Far more worrisome was his walk rate jumping through the roof. He dished out a free pass to a whopping 17.9% of opponents while in a Rangers uniform.

One of the few positives is that he continued to induce weak contact. Chafin induced an average exit velocity of 86.1 MPH with a 6.1% barrel rate. His BABIP returned to a much more sustainable .304 rate, but aside from that, Chafin's time with the Rangers this year did not go very well.

Now, the Rangers face a similar dilemma to the Mets' Maton issue. Do they pick up Chafin's option (which is worth $6.5 million) and bet on his good half season, or do they buy him out for $500K? Pirates fans should definitely keep an eye on this one. The Bucs only have one left-handed reliever on the 40-man roster (Joey Wentz). Chafin would be an intriguing lefty for the team to pursue if the Rangers end up buying him out.