Skip to main content

Pirates’ Rule 5 catching decision could reveal just how much they trust Henry Davis

It will be telling.
ByStephen Parello
Aug 25, 2026; San Diego, California, USA;  Pittsburgh Pirates catcher Henry Davis (32) dodges a pitch during the fourth inning against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park.  Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images
Aug 25, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; Pittsburgh Pirates catcher Henry Davis (32) dodges a pitch during the fourth inning against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The MLB Rule 5 Draft typically occurs during the Winter Meetings in December. With a lockout potentially on the way, beginning after the current CBA expires on December 1, the event is in peril. However, even in the event of a lockout, there's a chance that the draft is postponed, and the Pittsburgh Pirates must be ready.

The deadline to protect players from being selected in the Rule 5 Draft by adding them to the 40-man roster is November 17, and in one instance, what the Pirates decide to do will be very telling. Catcher Axiel Plaz is Pittsburgh's No. 7 prospect per MLB Pipeline, and after a stellar year in Greensboro in which he hit .305/.389/.513 with 18 homers, his future looks incredibly bright. He's also Rule 5 eligible this winter.

That's where the conundrum comes in. Plaz hasn't played above Hi-A, so the impact he'd have on the 2027 roster is minimal. However, the catcher position is thin throughout the league, and if the Rule 5 Draft happens, there's no guarantee that a desperate team won't take him and throw him in the deep end, hoping that he can swim.

Pittsburgh already has three catchers on its 40-man roster. There's Rafael Flores Jr., who looks like he could be a future building block if he can keep his small-sample-size magic going. Then there's Endy Rodriguez, who has a world of talent and some of the worst injury luck in the world. While there's uncertainty with both, it's hard to give up on either of them, which brings us to the third member of this group, Henry Davis.

Davis is a stellar defender, which is one of the most important things you want out of your catcher. However, the 27-year-old hit just .172/.272/.313 in 2026 and owns a career .565 OPS. All the defensive wizardry in the world doesn't make that play.

So here's the conundrum. If you add Plaz to the 40-man, you're not going to carry four catchers, which would make Davis the odd man out. However, if you do that, you're essentially saying that you're not going to use anyone other than Flores Jr. and Rodriguez in 2027.

The Pirates' Axiel Plaz Rule 5 decision rests entirely on whether or not they believe that Henry Davis is salvageable

Davis doesn't even need to be a good hitter to have value, but he does need to become someone who isn't an automatic out. There is actually some reason to believe that could be the case. While the results have been far from ideal over his career, he was the No. 1 overall pick in 2021 and has some tools to support that draft position.

The first thing that stands out is Davis's bat speed. At an average of 74.2 miles per hour, he has well above-average oomph in his swing. When he makes contact, that power plays and allows him to hit the ball hard, with a 90.3 miles per hour average exit velocity that is also significantly better than average.

The problem is that making contact is a big issue for Davis, and when he does connect, he does so at poor angles, stifling any chance he has at doing real damage.

The question is, do the Pirates believe that they could lead Davis to have a Patrick Bailey-type renaissance? Bailey was a glove-first backstop who was well below average at the dish with the San Francisco Giants, but morphed into a roughly league-average hitter with the Cleveland Guardians, posting a 99 OPS+ following his trade (including the playoffs).

If so, you risk losing Plaz, in part because Davis's veteran experience is valuable, and because you know that the organizational catching depth is strong and can sustain the hit. However, if you don't believe that Davis can find another gear offensively, you have a few days left to try to trade him to someone who has more faith that he can turn it around, or else you eventually DFA him when you need a 40-man roster spot.

All of this hinges on what the Pirates decide to do with Plaz, and their decision will be telling and could be the final nail in Davis' proverbial coffin.

Add us as a preferred source on Google