Pirates’ rumored free agent targets keep hinting at a depth chart ripple effect

All the buzz around the Pirates being possible spenders this offseason has been very exciting, representing a complete step in the right direction for the organization. While that news has been what fans want to hear, their reported targets have been somewhat odd, and could really shake up the depth chart.

Pittsburgh's targets have been primarily first basemen, with a reportedplan to offer Josh Naylor a large contract, and continuing links to Ryan O'Hearn from two MLB insiders. Both players would be significant boosts to their league-worst offense, but Spencer Horwitz was the Pirates' best hitter and already plays first base.

Is the plan to just add as many bats as possible, regardless of defense? Do they want to move Horwitz to second base? Are they seeking a quality DH to replace Andrew McCutchen? There are a handful of thoughts to take away from their targets, since they have all been first base/DH options (like Kyle Schwarber, for instance).

Pirates' rumored free agent targets suggest Pittsburgh may have a deep depth chart ripple.

If the thought is to move Horwitz to second base, that would not be too crazy. He played 288 innings there with Toronto and just six last season with the Pirates. With the Blue Jays, he accounted for -5 DRS with a 0 OAA and a 1.0 FRV. At first base in 2025, he generated +1 OAA and FRV. So, at either position, he's about an average defender. O'Hearn is a quality defensive first baseman, producing a six OAA and FRV. Having both in the lineup would be great, especially with the defensive bonus O'Hearn brings. This little plan brings up another problem with Nick Gonzales, though.

If Horwitz takes the second base job, what happens with Gonzales? Konnor Griffin has a solid chance of winning the Opening Day job at shortstop, so there isn't much room for Gonzales to have an everyday spot elsewhere. Maybe he'll platoon there against left-handed pitching. He was slightly better against southpaws than right-handers last year, but it was still below-average production overall.

The Pirates' rumored list of targets creates more questions than answers about their ultimate plan. They do not need a first baseman, yet they have only been connected to them. It's a bold strategy, presumably trying to get the best bats possible, regardless of where they play on defense. This plan needs to work, especially with all the hype around the team right now.