Pittsburgh Pirates: 5 Pitchers that Broke the Hearts of Fans Since 2005
The Pittsburgh Pirates have had some really promising pitchers over the last decade or so. However, a lot of them never reached their potential.
Since 2005, the Pittsburgh Pirates heavily invested in adding young pitching talent. Even when Neal Huntington became General Manager in 2007 this was clearly their goal in rebuilding the Minor League System. However, for as many pitchers as they brought in many of them never really progressed, especially at the Big League level.
Of course, there are starting pitchers in more recent memory like Tyler Glasnow and Nick Kingham both of who never found success with the Pirates. Both were highly touted, and they were expected to be key parts of this team's future. However, both made it very clear after a short amount of time that neither would be a part of the team's future rotation.
However, that was not always the case with these pitchers. The pitchers we will look at were not complete duds. They were able to pitch multiple seasons for the team and showed enough potential to actually believe in them. Let's take a look at the 5 pitcherssince 2005 who showed promise, and potential, but ultimately just broke the hearts of fans by not reaching their potential. These were pitchers who every time they looked to be turning a corner they would end up taking steps back:
#5, Charlie Morton, 2009-2015
Charlie Morton is an American starting pitcher who plays in currently plays for the Atlanta Braves Major League Baseball (MLB) for 14 seasons from 2008 to 2021. He spent the early part of his career with the Pittsburgh Pirates, where he established himself as a reliable and consistent starting pitcher.
Morton was drafted by the Atlanta Braves in the third round of the 2002 MLB draft. He made his major league debut with the Braves in 2008 before being traded to the Pirates in June 2009. Morton Morton was traded along with outfield prospect Gorkys Hernandez and left-handed pitching prospect Jeff Locke
Morton struggled in his first season with the Pirates, posting a 5.26 ERA in 18 starts. His next year was not much better, he missed significant time with shoulder fatigue. His ERA was over 9 at the time of the injury designation, when he would return he would be a bit more effective and get his ERA under 8.
However, Morton bounced back in a big way in 2011. He went 10-10 with a 3.83 ERA and struck out 110 batters in 171 2/3 innings pitched. He would not be able to replicate that success in 2012 as he would be shut down by the beginning of the season. He would evenutally undergo Tommy John Surgery in June of that year.
Morton was shut down with elbow discomfort and would undergo Tommy John Surgery. He would not return until the 2013 season, although a much-needed starting pitching reinforcement for what would be the breakthrough season for the Organization.
After being activated from the DL in 2013, Morton secured his first win of the season in a shutout against the Cincinnati Reds. Despite missing the beginning of the year Morton a 7-4 had a 3.26 ERA in 26 starts. On December 11, 2013, Morton inked a three-year extension with the Pirates, including a club option for the 2017 season. However, his 2014 campaign was hampered by injuries, and he was placed on the DL with right hip inflammation. Morton's season ended prematurely when he required hip surgery. For the 2014 season, he would pitch well once again earning a 3.72 ERA before the hip injury popped up.
This would also hamped him into 2015. He would undergo offseaosn surgery to help correct his hip issue. However, this would hamped him leading into the 2015 season. He would only make 23 starts and finish with an ERA just under 5. The Bucs decided that they needed to move on from Morton that following offseason and traded him to the Phillies.
Morton's career as a Pirate was very up and down. He pitched relatively well in Black and Gold, but injuries were consistently taking away too many innings for a player with that large of a contract. Obviously, hips, knees, elbows, and shoulders are all things that usually do not improve with age, but rather the opposite.
It was a mistake, Morton would go on to become a multiple World Series Champion. He would earn 2 All-Star appearances and finish 3rd for the Cy Young Award in 2019. That is the heartbreaking part about Charlie Morton. He had a nice career here in Pittsburg, everyone knew of his "electric stuff", but as always that success showed up elsewhere.
#4, Zach Duke, 2005-2010
In 2005 the Pittsburgh Pirates called up two of their better pitching prospect. One of those prospects was Paul Maholm and the other would be Zach Duke. Duke would show a lot of flashes in his 2005 stint and give a lot of hope to fans of the Pittsburgh Pirates about the future of the rotation for the team.
Zach Duke is a former American professional baseball pitcher who played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for 14 seasons from 2005 to 2019. He was born on April 19, 1983, in Clifton, Texas, and attended Midway High School in Waco, Texas. Duke was a left-handed pitcher and primarily played for the Pittsburgh Pirates during his career.
Duke was drafted by the Pittsburgh Pirates in the 20th round of the 2001 MLB draft. He made his major league debut on July 2, 2005, against the Milwaukee Brewers, and pitched a complete game, allowing only two runs and striking out five batters. Duke had an impressive rookie season in 2005, finishing with an 8-2 record and a 1.81 ERA in 14 starts. His best season was in 2009 when he pitched to a 3.29 ERA in the first half. However, his ERA would be over 5 for the second part of the season. This carried into 2011 when he made 29 starts with an ERA pushing 6. The Bucs would trade Duke to the Diamondbacks ending his career as a Pirate.
Over his career, Duke played for six different teams, including the Pittsburgh Pirates, Arizona Diamondbacks, Washington Nationals, Milwaukee Brewers, St. Louis Cardinals, and Cincinnati Reds. He finished his career with a record of 71-101 and a 4.54 ERA. Duke was primarily a starting pitcher early in his career but transitioned to a reliever in his later years. A pitcher who showed a lot of promise at times, but could not find consistency. Many in the fan base wanted Duke to succeed but he could never put it all together.
#3, Paul Maholm, 2005-2012
After his collegiate career, Paul Maholm was drafted by the Pittsburgh Pirates in the first round (eighth overall) of the 2003 MLB Draft. He quickly rose through the Pirates' minor league system and made his MLB debut on August 30, 2005, against the Milwaukee Brewers. Maholm struggled in his first season, going 3-10 with a 5.53 ERA in 17 starts.
However, Maholm improved in his second season, going 8-10 with a 4.76 ERA in 29 starts. He continued to improve over the next few seasons, becoming a reliable starter for the Pirates. In 2008, Maholm had a breakout season, going 9-9 with a 3.71 ERA in 31 starts. He followed that up with a solid 2009 campaign, going 8-9 with a 4.44 ERA in 29 starts.
Maholm continued to pitch well for the Pirates, but the team struggled to compete, finishing with losing records every season from 2005 to 2011. In the 201-2012 offseason, the Pirates declined their option on the left-hander. Maholm would end up signing with the division rival Cubs later that offseason. A first-round pick, a lefty too, who just never reached their potential and was not even a trade chip for the team.
#2, James McDonald, 2010-2013
James McDonald is a former American professional baseball pitcher who played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for six seasons from 2008 to 2014. He spent the majority of his career with the Pittsburgh Pirates, where he established himself as a promising young pitcher.
McDonald was drafted by the Los Angeles Dodgers in the 11th round of the 2002 MLB draft. He made his major league debut with the Dodgers in 2008 but was traded to the Pirates in 2010. McDonald quickly made an impact with the Pirates, posting a 4.24 ERA in 11 starts in his first season with the team.
However, it was in 2012 that McDonald had his breakout season with the Pirates. He finished the year with a 12-8 record and a 4.21 ERA in 30 starts. He also set career highs in innings pitched (171) and strikeouts (151) that season. McDonald was a key part of the Pirates' rotation that season, which helped the team reach the postseason for the first time in 21 years.
Despite his success in 2012, McDonald struggled in the following seasons. Injuries and inconsistency plagued his career, and he never regained the form that he showed in his breakout season. McDonald was released by the Pirates in September 2013 and spent the 2014 season with the Chicago Cubs before being released again.
Overall, McDonald spent four seasons with the Pirates, pitching in 98 games and finishing with a record of 18-27 and a 4.34 ERA. While he may not have lived up to the promise he showed in 2012, he was a valuable member of the Pirates pitching staff during his time in Pittsburgh. Still, it is hard to think about what McDonald's future could have been. He had one of the more live arms that the Bucs had coming up at the time and one of the best-looking curveballs in the division. Unfortunately, when it looked like he was evolving into a next-level pitcher he instead regressed.
#1, Bryan Morris, 2008-2015
Bryan Morris is a former American professional baseball pitcher who played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for six seasons from 2012 to 2017. He spent the majority of his career with the Pittsburgh Pirates, where he established himself as a reliable and consistent bullpen arm. Which in lies the problem. This is a bit different than the previous 4, as Morris dissapointed us by not ever becoming a starting pitcher at the Big League level.
Morris was drafted by the Los Angeles Dodgers in the first round of the 2006 MLB draft. He spent several seasons in the Dodgers' minor league system before being traded to the Pirates in 2008. Morris made his major league debut with the Pirates in 2012 and spent the next three seasons with the team as a valuable member of the bullpen.
Morris' best season with the Pirates came in 2014 when he posted a 3.52 ERA in 70 appearances out of the bullpen. He also recorded 21 holds and two saves that season. Morris was known for his ability to induce ground balls, which made him a valuable asset to the Pirates' pitching staff.
Morris' time with the Pirates came to an end in 2014 when he was traded to the Miami Marlins in exchange for a competitive balance draft pick. He spent the 2015 season with the Marlins before being traded again, this time to the San Francisco Giants. Morris played one more season in the majors in 2017, splitting time between the Giants and the Toronto Blue Jays, before being released and ultimately retiring from baseball.
Overall, Morris spent three seasons with the Pirates, pitching in 137 games and finishing with a record of 8-8 and a 3.46 ERA. While his numbers may seem okay and he did help with key bullpen innings, Morris left a lot to be desired. Morris along with Andy LaRoche were the two primary prospects in the Jason Bay deal. Morris was a first-round pick and was supposed to be one of the best pitching prospects in Baseball by the time of the trade. Instead, he was a reliever who would eventually be traded for Gaby Sanchez, a platoon first baseman.