Pittsburgh Pirates: Ben Cherington Needs to be Better

Houston Astros v Pittsburgh Pirates
Houston Astros v Pittsburgh Pirates / Justin Berl/GettyImages
3 of 3
Next

A lot can be said about the Pittsburgh Pirates over the last two months of the season. We have made it known on Twitter our displeasure with how things have gone. While a lot of the blame can easily be placed on the players or the coaches, Ben Cherington needs to be held more accountable and also start treating the fan base better.

What do I mean by this? Earlier this week he basically admitted that the Pittsburgh Pirates, who now have a losing record, have surpassed their expectations:

Congrats, you surprised teams because we are not on track to lose 100 games again? Everyone can see what has taken place in the last month of the season. The holes on this team are becoming more and more glaring by the day yet the answers are Minor League journeymen.

The Pittsburgh Pirates got off to a great start and everything was great. Then the fan base was quickly shown that they need not get too excited. The Oneil Cruz injury shook this team there is no doubt about that at this point. Since he has been out of the lineup the team is 19-24. They played really well at first, but they took advantage of some other poor teams like the Reds, Cardinals, and Rockies.

However, whenever they were swept by Tampa it was shown that this offense was missing the threat of Oneil Cruz. Instead, they replaced him with Chris Owings. Nothing against Chris Owings he has had a Major League career and is a fine veteran. However, he is not an impact player at any level. Yes, this team needed someone who could play shortstop, but they also decided to leave Tucapita Marcano down instead.

Ben Cherington did not prioritize bringing up the best talent available at the position, who HAS Major League experience. Instead, he presented the clubhouse with a guy that will probably be off the roster before the All-Star Break. There is no sense of urgency to win shown in a move like that, especially to a clubhouse and fan base that knows they are exceeding expectations.

Instead, Ben Cherington has basically told us to be patient we aren't supposed to be this good yet. Just like Neal Huntington use to do, pushing their vision onto the fan base like we are not watching what is taking place. Super-2 is a word that no one wants to hear or talk about. In a day and age when there is more exposure to prospects and their numbers it is hard to hide talent.

So stop trying to. Stop with saying they need more time behind the plate in Endy Rodriguez and Henry Davis's case. The fan base is not buying it, not right now. We have been told for the last 3.5 years to trust the process the Front Office was putting into play.

We have, yet nothing seems different. Our best player is out of the lineup, the offense is struggling, and our two best bats in the minors can't come up because of this Front Office being complacent with another season heading in the wrong direction. Ben Cherington came into the Pittsburgh Pirates Organization preaching changes, and how things were going to be more player oriented.

Instead, we are seeing the same manipulation that we saw from the last regime. Henry Davis has been one of the more impressive hitters at Double-A this year, his reward has been to stay at Double-A. The former #1 overall selection is mashing the ball in the upper minors and the team needs offense but yet nothing changes. Instead, we get Josh Palacios and Miguel Andujar.

Also in the case of the catchers needing more time behind the dish to learn, why can they not do that at the Big League level? Austin Hedges is supposed to be just a catcher's-catcher so why wouldn't they learning from him be super valuable? Also, Henry Davis more so than Endy has seen time at other positions in the field, so are we purely focused on them improving behind the dish?

The other comical part of this is the number of mental mistakes and errors that the Pittsburgh Pirates have had this year. A lot of fans have called it "little league errors" which is not far off. The answer to that is the team is young and still learning. So why are they contradicting themselves? If they are okay with guys like Jack Suwinski and Rodolfo Castro making mistakes because they are learning, then why can't the same be said for Henry Davis and Endy Rodriguez?

Because none of it is true. It is all about Super-2 status and not about the urgency to win. Here we are on the cusp of June, about the time when teams start to be less concerned with it. Super-2 is not an exact date but a formula based on service time, which is extremely complicated. Anyhow it typically falls sometime in June.

If the player gets the proper amount of service time, then they become eligible for a fourth year of arbitration which could mean multiple millions of dollars. This is more than a team like the Bucs want to spend or project to spend. That also would not affect the Organization until 6 seasons down the road. That is the joke of it, it is not an immediate consequence. If the player is still on your team at that point then he probably is worth the money you are paying him.

Ben Cherington needs to start turning this around. The spark this fan base had from good baseball was the most excitement for the Bucs in years. Instead of going for it and calling up the best players (who are Big League-ready), we settle for the hopes that we do not have to pay these players too much more than we have to. Is it about winning? How can it be when we sit here on the cusp of June knowing that Endy Rodriguez and/or Henry Davis are still in the minors? But there will be a relief as Super-2 passes they will call up their two best-hitting prospects.

It is Ben Cherington's way out, the calendar keeps moving. All he had to do was kick the can down the road for an extra month and now here were are with a better record than he expected and now he will promote his hitters like he is making an aggressive impactful move. When really if he was urgent about winning he would have made that move a month ago instead of watching the offense drown and the fan base with it. We know the Super-2 game stop with the half-truths and misdirecting.

Next