Pittsburgh Pirates Poll Results: What is Pushing Free Agents Away?

San Francisco Giants v Chicago Cubs
San Francisco Giants v Chicago Cubs / Michael Reaves/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates' offseason has been a bit of a disappointment, to say the least. In a recent poll conducted on Rumbunter's Twitter, fans expressed a combination of frustration and speculation, attempting to unravel the mysteries behind the Pirates' lackluster player acquisitions. All in all, it all equates to more of the same, the Pittsburgh Pirates do not look like a contending team heading into the 2024 season.

As the offseason commenced, optimism was relatively high for Pirates faithful. The Front Office made it sound like they were going to be making some impact additions and the team performed much better in 2023 than expected. However, the reality has been far from the envisioned scenario, with each player on the team expressing interest in ultimately choosing to go elsewhere. This trend has prompted fans to scrutinize the underlying reasons for the team's challenges in bolstering the roster.

A Twitter poll we put out sought to gauge fans thoughts, posing a straightforward question about the primary reason that is leading to players choosing other teams. The responses and results are as follows:

The majority of respondents attributed the team's struggles to financial constraints, labeling the Pirates as "cheap." This viewpoint aligns with the prevailing notion that small-market teams often face challenges in competing financially with their larger-market counterparts. However, we as fans also know that their owner, Bob Nutting, simply prefers business over winning.

A significant portion of fans believe that the Pirates are grappling with challenges in attracting free agents to Pittsburgh. Whether it be due to recent on-field struggles or other factors, the perception among fans is that players are opting for alternative destinations over the Steel City. One would think that getting to play at PNC Park would be an attractive option due to the nature of the ballpark and the quality. However, there are obviously much more important factors at play for free agents.

The smallest group of voters has dissatisfaction with the front office, implying that the team's management may be falling short in their pursuit of impactful signings. Fellow Site Expert Marty Leap is one of these people. He believes that the Front Office simply is not going about free agency and/or the offseason in a way that will work for the Organization.

Fans of the Pittsburgh Pirates acknowledged the complexity of the situation, recognizing that these factors may not be mutually exclusive but rather all related.

Reports indicating the Pirates' financial competitiveness in negotiations add a layer of uncertainty, leaving fans wondering about the true nature of the team's current scenario. Reports are that the Bucs offered Sean Manaea the best contract, yet he chose elsewhere. He wanted to play for a contender, something that Pirates obviously are not viewed as by many.

The poll results suggest a collective sentiment of frustration and concern about the team's ability to make significant strides in player acquisitions. The quest for answers continues as the Pittsburgh Pirates navigate the rest of this offseason. Those answers need to be players who can help this team and not just more of the same.