Pittsburgh Pirates: Should Have Sold High on Wil Crowe

Chicago White Sox v Pittsburgh Pirates
Chicago White Sox v Pittsburgh Pirates / Justin K. Aller/GettyImages
1 of 2
Next

The Pittsburgh Pirates should have sold high on Wil Crowe last season. It is easy to say now, no one expected him to go from one of the more dominant relievers in the National League to struggling to have successful outings. But, here we are.

One thing that made the previous regime successful was their ability to sell high on relief pitching. It seemed like every year the Bucs had one of the best bullpens in the National League despite not spending much financially into it. That was because the Front Office was not afraid to sell high on their relief pitchers.

Relief pitchers are volatile. Many of them are in the bullpen for a reason, struggling to command their pitches consistently. Eventually for most relievers they get caught up to, their two pitch pitchers and eventually opposing hitters figure them out. Also, throw in some injuries and that can of course expedite the downward trajectory of a relief pitcher.

The Bucs missed the boat last year. The previous regime had such success dealing away their top-end reliever, but they also knew when to. The team sold high on Joel Hanrahan and brought in Mark Melancon along with 3 other prospects. The move was heavily criticized at the time but worked out as Melancon would go on to be the team's closer for years to come. Hanrahan would only throw 7.1 innings for the Red Sox before an injury forced him into retirement.

The team also went under a lot of heat for when they traded former first-round pick turned successful reliever Brad Lincoln. Lincoln was looking like a future backend of the bullpen arm, but the team traded him for outfield Travis Snider. Lincoln would go on to struggle after the deal and would be out of the League by the end of 2014.

There were a couple of other deals that worked out well also. The team traded lefty reliever Justin Wilson to the Yankees for catcher Francisco Cervelli. They traded lefty reliever Tony Watson to the Dodgers in exchange for then prospect Oneil Cruz. The final sell-high was Mark Melancon himself. Melancon was traded to the Nationals in exchange for two pitchers including Wil Crowe.

It would have been wise for the Pittsburgh Pirates to deal reliever Wil Crowe last season.

In the first half of the 2022 season, Crowe would pitch to an impressive 3.33 ERA and striking out nearly 1 per inning. The 2nd half was a disaster for Crowe, pitching to a 6.66 ERA and showing that he was not capable of pitching in the 9th inning. It is easy to look back and say the team should have sold high on Crowe, much like was done with Brad Lincoln many years ago. If David Bednar doesn't get hurt who knows what may have happened at the 2022 Deadline.

Next