Pittsburgh Pirates: Three First Base Options in Free Agency (And One via Trade!)

The Pittsburgh Pirates need to address their first base situation this off-season. Here are some potential options to address that need.

The Pittsburgh Pirates find themselves in a pivotal off-season, seeking to address multiple gaps on the team, including first base. The team's need for improved offense, especially against right-handed pitching, has become one of the priorities this off-season, whether it happens through free agency or via trade.

The Pirates have historically been reluctant to spend big money on the corner position and that will be the same expectation this winter, especially with a weaker hitting market than in past seasons. The first domino in free agency for this market fell this week with Jeimer Candelario signing a 3-year $45M deal with Cincinnati.

The Pirates must be active in addressing this issue in order to keep pace with the other teams in the NL Central. So far this off-season the only major league bat added has been catcher Ali Sanchez. With the free agency slowly gaining traction let's take a look at three free agent options that would make sense.

Donovan Solano

Donovan Solano is a right-handed hitter who spent this past season with the Minnesota Twins, hitting .282/.369/.391 (116 wRC+) in 450 PA, producing a 1.2 fWAR. Solano is a line-drive oriented hitter and has great control of the bat. He played primarily first base for the Twins, but also saw time at second base, third base, and DH while helping the Twins win the AL Central division.

According to Baseball Savant Solano ranked in the 99th percentile of sweet spot percentage, which measures the number of batted balls hit with a launch angle between 8 and 32 degrees, or in other words hit with a good angle such as line drives. While Solano has very little power production his average exit velocity sat around 90 MPH, producing hard contact a lot of the time.

Solano is different from the other players on this list in that he's a right-handed hitter rather than left-handed; however, his splits against righties have been fairly good. In 2023 he produced a 120 wRC+ against left-handed pitching and a 110 wRC+ against right-handed pitching. That would be in improvement for the Pirates on both sides of the ball and make this more than a platoon addition like some of the others in this list.

As mentioned Solano is also capable of playing second base, another area that the Pirates need to address. Second baseman Liover Peguero struggled greatly against right-handed pitching, producing just a 54 wRC+ against right-handed pitchers as opposed to a 114 wRC+ vs lefties. Solano would fill that hole easily and give the Pirates more flexibility in putting together the 26-man roster.

He's likely to get a deal in the neighborhood of 1-year $10M this off-season, but that could be lowered by adding a second year to the contract. It's more expensive than the other options on this list, but is the best option overall.

Mike Ford

Mike Ford is a left-handed hitter who spent this past season with the Seattle Mariners. He hit .228/.323/.475 (123 wRC+) with 16 home runs in 251 plate appearances last season before being non-tendered by the Mariners. He primarily was the DH for the Mariners, seeing only 54 innings there this season, but is capable enough for the position.

Ford has power that the Pirates desperately lack, cracking 16 homers in just 251 PA last season, barreling the ball at a 17.3% rate which would be among the best of qualified hitters. He did his damage all against right-handed pitching and producing a 117 wRC+ against those pitchers. He's fared well against left-handed pitching in his career as well, producing a 147 wRC+ in 108 career PAs.

Ford gives the Pirates both an option at first base and at DH and would be a great platoon partner for Connor Joe at first base. He's one of the more inexpensive bats in this free agent class but one with enough impact power to make the move work out for the Pirates. He should only cost around $3M in free agency.

Josh Naylor

We've covered three potential free agents in this article that could fit the Pirates' needs heading into 2024, but that's not the only way the Pirates can address that need this winter. Cleveland has been taking calls on various players this off-season and one of them is their starting first-baseman Josh Naylor.

Naylor has emerged as an impactful hitter in the Guardian's lineup and is reportedly on the market. Last season he hit .308/.354/.489 (128 wRC+) in 495 PA with 17 HR and 31 doubles, producing a 2.5 fWAR as the Guardians' primary first baseman. Naylor gives the Pirates an everyday option to use at first base, DH, or even see time in the outfield. He crushes righties (129 wRC+) as much as he crushes lefties (127 wRC+), giving the Pirates more than just a platoon option.

Naylor is a solid defender at first base, collecting 5 outs above average (OAA), which ranks him the 88th percentile. He struck out just 13.7% of the time, ranking him in the top 94 percentile across baseball which, like Smith, would be a huge gain for this Pirates lineup. If you saw the Guardians play at PNC park this summer then you already know what he can do as he cranked 3 home runs and drove in 9 RBIs in 2 starts.

Naylor is under control for the next 2 seasons, his final years under arbitration. He is estimated to make around $7M in arbitration this year, giving the Pirates a middle-of-the-lineup bat at a rate far below the amount it would take to lock up a similar bat in free agency. It would likely take a trio of prospects to acquire Naylor, who plays with his brother Bo in Cleveland, but the move would more than pay dividends not only this season, but the following season as well.

Conclusion

In evaluating these options, the Pirates should consider not only this season, but the seasons that follow. First base is a huge hole not only at the major league level, but across the minors as well. Attempts to fill this void have seen players stall in their development as they reached the upper minors, forcing the Pirates to be creative in their approach.

Whether they accomplish this through a platoon of Ford or Smith, or by acquiring an everyday bat like Solano, the Pirates must do something to fill the position with quality at-bats across the entire season. Whichever option they go should also still allow the Pirates to be flexible in their lineup crafting, meaning someone who can play multiple positions.

Preferred Option: Josh Naylor

Naylor is beyond the perfect fit for this hole. He gives the Pirates a solid everyday first baseman who can hit both lefties and righties, provide impact power to the middle of the order, and give the Pirates an option to play in right-field or at DH if necessary. He's also entering what would be considered his "peak years" and slowly emerging as one of the better bats in baseball.

If the Pirates would go with a platoon-oriented free agent I would like to see them add Smith over Ford for both the defensive flexibility and the fact that Smith look great in the final month of the season. I would hope, however, that the Pirates are looking for more than just a plug and play bat, rather someone who can help the Pirates now and in the future.

As the Pirates navigate the offseason, addressing the first base position will be crucial to shaping a competitive roster for the 2024 season. Whether through free agency or a trade, the Pirates must not be complacent with what they have internally and instead be proactive in finding a solution.