Pittsburgh Pirates: Under-the-Radar Pitchers to Target in Free Agency

In an effort to bolster their pitching staff, the Pittsburgh Pirates could pursue these five free agents this offseason

The Pittsburgh Pirates have a vital offseason ahead and must make some roster moves, mostly in the starting rotation, to reinforce a team that could be a contender. The Pirate pitching staff is still uncertain, but if they do pursue pitchers this offseason, these five could be possible acquisitions.

No. 5 Michael Lorenzen

Michael Lorenzen was a huge trade deadline acquisition for the Phillies, but he struggled massively with them after throwing a no-hitter and was left on the postseason roster. Lorenzen could be a steal as he has the potential to have a massive 2024 campaign after starting the 2023 season off well with the Detroit Tigers, which included him being selected for the All-Star Game.

So far, Lorenzen's career has spanned nine seasons with the Reds, Angels, Tigers, and Phillies. At times he shows his potential to be part of any team's starting rotation, but then at other times, he isn't even close to league average.

Lorenzen's career has never really gotten the chance to thrive with any team as the Reds decided to use him more as a reliever, and once he finally turned into a starter with the Angels in 2022, he struggled. But in 2023, he emerged as a viable starting pitcher with the Tigers. With less pressure on him, he could be a breakout candidate for the Pirates, who need a good inning-eating pitcher, which is what Lorenzen can be.

No. 4 Trevor May

Trevor May has had a strong career as a reliever who can close games and started some previously. In 2023, May was mostly a closer for the Athletics, where he showed his potential to be a key piece in the bullpen after struggling with the Mets in 2022.

May will be going into his tenth season at age 34, but coming off his best season ever. If the Pirates could sign him to reinforce the back of the bullpen, they could emerge as one of the best. May struggled to start the season with the Athletics, which is a given when you don't get any run support. But in his small sample size of 46 innings, he did well with a 3.28 ERA.

In 2023, May struggled a bit with his control and gave up a career-high in walks, but he didn't give up as many hits or runs. His main problem with signing with the Pirates is that his costs are quite steep, as he has earned at least $7 million a year for the past three seasons with the Mets and Athletics. It's unknown if the Pirates will target May, but it could be possible.

No. 3 Johnny Cueto

Johnny Cueto didn't pitch much in 2023, but when he did, he struggled. It seems likely the Marlins will decline his 2024 club option worth $10.5 million and instead will give him $2.5 million as a buyout. Cueto wouldn't be new to Pittsburgh as he pitched against the Pirates in the 2013 Wild Card Game versus the Pirates, in which the Reds lost after Cueto gave up four runs.

Cueto is now 37 years old, but he still has much more left in the tank after his amazing 2022 campaign with the Chicago White Sox, which earned him a contract with the Marlins. But in 2023, he started the season off hurt and didn't get much playing time.

When he did pitch in 2023, he started ten games, played in thirteen, and finished one of them. He only pitched in 52 innings to an ERA of 6.02, which was kind of to be expected when you play hurt.

The Pirates are hoping to make the playoffs soon, and Cueto has playoff experience and even helped the Kansas City Royals win the World Series in 2015 when he threw a complete game, only giving up one run in the 2015 World Series.

No. 2 Jack Flaherty

Jack Flaherty was expected to be a massive 2023 trade deadline acquisition for the Baltimore Orioles, who have gone on to win their division and make the playoffs. But Flaherty has been one of the worst acquisitions at the deadline and barely is pitching now.

In previous years with the St. Louis Cardinals, Flaherty was showing he could be the next ace of the Cardinals, replacing Adam Wainwright, but that all failed after struggling in the 2022 season, which never stopped happening, including struggles in the 2023 season too.

After getting traded to the Orioles, Flaherty pitched in nine games, and he hasn't shown much, pitching to an ERA of 6.75 while costing them many games. His many struggles have been giving up hits because after his trade to the Orioles, he actually started to walk fewer people, but the hit rate skyrocketed to an unbearable rate.

Flaherty's two best MLB seasons were 2018 and 2019, the latter of which saw him finish fourth in Cy Young voting and even got some MVP votes. The Pirates are known to be able to revive the careers of former star pitchers, and that could be a huge possibility with Flaherty, who is still only 27 years old and could be a long-term solution for the Pirates' rotation.