Should the Pittsburgh Pirates consider going after Alek Manoah?

Two years ago, one of the best pitchers in baseball was Toronto Blue Jays' right-hander Alek Manoah. Manoah finished third in American League Cy Young voting. This was after an outstanding rookie campaign as well. But fast forward to 2024, and Manoah is struggling for the Blue Jays' A-Ball affiliate. At this point, the Blue Jays might just try and salvage whatever they can get from Manoah, and if they're willing to sell low on the former Cy Young finalist, should the Pittsburgh Pirates consider going after him? What would the pros and cons be, and would it be worth the Pirates' time and resources?

The Jays drafted Manoah in the 2019 draft in the first round and quickly ascended to the Major Leagues. He opened his career off with a 2.60 ERA, 3.51 FIP, and 1.01 WHIP through his first 308.1 innings in the Major Leagues between 2021 and 2022. He had above average, albeit not elite, peripherals, including a 24.7 percent strikeout rate, 7.3 percent walk rate, and 0.82 HR/9. Manoah's strong suit was limiting hard contact with an 87.3 MPH exit velocity and 5.5 percent barrel rate. Between these two seasons, the only other starters with a lower barrel rate were Corbin Burnes and Max Fried. He finished tied with Logan Webb and Luis Castillo, and he also had the eighth-lowest exit velocity and fourth-lowest hard-hit rate (31.4 percent).

However, then came 2023, and Manoah fell off a cliff. He only pitched 87 innings before being demoted to the minor leagues after posting a 5.87 ERA, 6.01 FIP, and 1.74 WHIP. His once solid peripherals also had a dramatic fall, with just a 19 percent strikeout rate, 1.55 HR/9, and a horrid 14.2 percent walk rate. After being one of the best soft-contact pitchers in 2021-2022, Manoah gave up hard contact like it was going out of stock. His exit velocity and hard-hit rate rose dramatically to 89.5 MPH and 44.4 percent, respectively, but more worrying was his 9 percent barrel rate. Manoah also lost a tick off his velocity, dropping from 93.9 MPH in '22 to 92.9 MPH in '23.

Now that we know who Manoah is let's look at reasons why the Pirates should and shouldn't go after Manoah.

Why the Pirates should consider going after Manoah

The most obvious reason is Manoah is still not that far removed from being an All-Star caliber pitcher. He's also only 26, and one bad year doesn't define a career. The Pirates could also use the depth on the 40-man roster. The Pirates will probably call Paul Skenes up sooner rather than later, but even then, he's just one person. If there are injuries, the Pirates are going to have to turn to Domingo German or Eric Lauer until Mike Burrows is back, assuming he's fully ready to go sometime during the second half of the season.

The Pirates also traded Jackson Wolf after designating him for assignment, removing another potential starter the Pirates could have called upon if need be. JT Brubaker's trade to the New York Yankees also eliminated another second-half rotation option if they needed it.

The second reason is that he's a sinkerball pitcher, and the Pirates love sinkerballers. He throws his sinker over a quarter of the time. His four-seamer is still his most used offering, but you could consider his sinker a primary pitch in his arsenal. His velocity is also back up as he sat 94 MPH with his sinker and fastball in his A-Ball debut. The only thing that's missing is that he's a left-hander.

Lastly, Ben Cherington also loves his former Blue Jays reclamation projects. Manoah was drafted while Cherington was the vice president of baseball operations for the Blue Jays. In Cherington's defense, his Blue Jays reclamation projects haven't been bad pick-ups. Ryan Borucki has been a great pick-up, and Rowdy Tellez is off to a good start to 2024. Even though he wasn't the best former Blue Jay ever, Anthony Alford still provided the Pirates a 96 OPS+ when healthy.

Why the Pirates shouldn't consider going after Manoah

I mean, Manoah's performance speaks for itself. An ERA approaching 6.00, a FIP over 6.00, he was awful in 2023. Even in 2021 and 2022, his underlying ERA estimators weren't great. He had a 4.05 xFIP, 3.85 SIERA, and a league average DRA-. Is this someone the Pirates want to call on, even in a depth situation? Eric Lauer or Domingo German could probably post an ERA below 6.00. That's not a full guarantee from Manoah.

Yes, it was only one bad year in less than 100 innings pitched, but he's looked worse since getting sent down to the minor leagues. He pitched 7.2 innings last year after getting demoted, allowing 13 earned runs, five walks, two home runs, and striking out 13 batters. In two minor league starts this year, he has pitched just five innings, allowing 10 runs on 13 hits while walking five.

There's also other issues that don't even pertain to his on-field performance. Manoah reportedly came into 2023 Spring Training weighing 320 pounds. In his defense, he came into Spring Training 2024 looking much healthier, but there's other issues that need to be addressed. Manoah reportedly refused to report to Triple-A when the Jays attempted to option him.

Finally, where would he fit on the roster? The Pirates would have to send him to Triple-A. At the time of writing this, Pirates starters have reeled off seven straight quality starts (at least six innings of work with three or fewer earned runs). Four of those starts include no walks allowed. Josh Fleming has been excellent as the Bucs' multi-inning reliever this year. Aside from David Bednar having some poor command to start the year, the bullpen has been pretty good for the most part.