Three underrated extension candidates for the Pittsburgh Pirates

Many Pittsburgh Pirates fans are likely anticipating another core piece of the team to get an extension within the next year or so. Since 2022, they've signed Ke'Bryan Hayes, Bryan Reynolds, and Mitch Keller to long-term deals. Both Hayes' and Reynolds' deals broke what was at the time the highest paid contract in the franchise's history, the latter being the first $100+ million contract the Pirates ever signed. One of Oneil Cruz Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, David Bednar, or even one of the other top prospects in the system could be next.

But the Pirates have some other players on their roster who they could definitely benefit from extending. These players are not prime extension candidates, but have been productive players for the Bucs and signing them now could very much help this team in the long run.

Ryan Borucki

The Pirates signed Ryan Borucki to a minor league deal in May 2023. Borucki was originally a promising young starter for the Toronto Blue Jays in 2018, but injuries derailed his next few seasons, as he pitched only 72.1 innings from 2019 through 2022. The low-cost flier on Borucki ended up being one of the best minor league pick-ups not just by the Pirates but by most teams in baseball last year.

Borucki pitched 40.1 innings with the Pirates, working to a 2.45 ERA, 3.35 FIP, and 0.74 WHIP. The southpaw's 21.7% strikeout rate was slightly below the league average, but that's about the only negative toward Borucki's first season in Pittsburgh. He had just a 2.6% walk rate and held opponents to a .181 batting average. Borucki was great at limiting home runs with an 0.89 HR/9 rate and didn't allow a single long ball in his final 17 frames of the season.

Borucki was great at inducing soft contact with an exit velocity and hard-hit rate of just 85.7 MPH and 28.8%. He was also good at inducing ground balls with a 46.8% GB%, which helped him post a robust 6.3% barrel rate. Borucki eventually worked himself into higher leverage situations by September and is set to play a prominent role in the Pirates' bullpen this year.

2024 is the last year of Borucki's contract, so it would make sense for the Pirates to try and get a deal done mid-season. He's a good left-handed reliever, and that's something you don't find easily. Borucki just turned 30 on Sunday, March 31st. I think a two-year deal with a third-year option would get the job done. Borucki might not be the first extension candidate you think of on the Pirates, but I'd love to see Borucki stick around for a few more years.

Pittsburgh has quietly built a team that can contend for the NL Central, and you can win big if you can predict just one of their wins this week at FanDuel! All you have to do is sign up, deposit $10 or more and then bet $5 or more on the Pirates to win. If Pittsburgh wins, you'll get $200 in bonus bets! Click this link to sign up with FanDuel today!

Connor Joe

Connor Joe has had a winding road to and from Pittsburgh. Originally a first-round competitive balance pick by the Pirates in 2014, the Pirates traded Joe to the Atlanta Braves in 2017 for Sean Rodriguez. Joe never appeared in the Majors for Atlanta, as he was then shipped to the LA Dodgers for international bonus money. The next off-season, he was selected by the Cincinnati Reds out of the Rule 5 draft and traded to the San Francisco Giants, where he appeared in eight MLB games, but later was returned to the Dodgers. The Colorado Rockies then signed him, where he spent the 2021 and 2022 seasons before being shipped back to Pittsburgh for minor leaguer Nick Garcia.

Joe's first season back in black and gold was solid, as he hit .247/.339/.421 with a .332 wOBA and 107 wRC+ through 472 plate appearances. The first baseman/outfielder hit for about league-average pop with a .174 isolated slugging percentage and 11 home runs. Joe drew walks quite frequently, with a 10.6% walk rate. His 23.3% strikeout rate was only slightly worse than the league average, which overall left him as an above-average hitter in 2023. He had some ups and downs throughout the season but showed some improvements in the second half of the campaign.

Joe split his time between the corner outfield and first base. Between the two, he spent more time in left/right field, where he logged 543.1 innings. He was not bad defensively in the grass, with -3 defensive runs saved, but +1 out above average and a 90.4 MPH outfield throw velocity, which was in the top 84th percentile of players. His first base defense also was respectable, with -2 DRS, but +1 OAA, and +5.5 UZR/150 in 343.2 innings.

Joe has more control remaining than Borucki, a lot more. He doesn't become a free agent until after the 2027 season, which means he has four full years of control remaining. But an extension now could save some money in arbitration later. Plus, the Pirates might be able to buy out a year or two of free agency. But Joe is already 31 and will be 32 by the end of the season, so he's not a young gun. Still, having Joe under contract and not worrying about arbitration, as well as potentially buying a year or two of his free agency, would be a smart move on the Pirates' end.