Rum Bunter
FanSided

Underrated 20-and-under prospects in the Pittsburgh Pirates’ farm system

The Pirates have a multitude of young prospects who deserve some recognition.

ByNoah Wright|
Jun 20, 2023; Phoenix, AZ, USA; Draft prospect Luke Scherrer during a high school baseball game at the MLB Draft Combine at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
Jun 20, 2023; Phoenix, AZ, USA; Draft prospect Luke Scherrer during a high school baseball game at the MLB Draft Combine at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images | Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
3 of 3

Luke Scherrer

The Pirates signed Luke Scherrer as an undrafted free agent after the 2023 draft. Scherrer, who was committed to Cal Poly, instead opted to head into pro ball after high school. The catching prospect got his first extended look at pro action this past season at the Florida Complex League, and while the numbers were solid, his scouting reports are definitely intriguing.

Scherrer slashed .273/.406/.345 through 139 plate appearances. Although he hit for very little power, with zero home runs and an isolated slugging percentage below .100, he did walk at a high rate of 12.9% and only struck out 15.9% of the time. This resulted in a quality .385 wOBA and 118 wRC+. Scherrer split his season almost evenly between catcher and first base and also saw a few innings in right field.

Scherrer was ranked as Perfect Game's 131st-best prospect. His defense might be his strongest suit. He displayed an incredible 1.80-second pop time. For reference, the average fastest pop time in baseball this season belongs to JT Realmuto at 1.85 seconds. He also flashed a very accurate throwing arm and had very good footwork behind the dish. Although it can't be measured, Scherrer has also shown off a strong baseball IQ, per Prospects Live.

His best offensive tool is his hit tool. He has a quick bat with a compact swing. Scherrer has the potential for above-average raw pop. According to Prospects Live, Scherrer has a strong lower half of his body that helps him get power to his pull side. He has all the tools to be a good hitter, along with a good fielder.

Scherrer is only 19 (turns 20 in December) but should see time at Bradenton next season. He is the best prospect on today's list, and based on some of the reports on him, he could very well be someone to watch next season. Scherrer has flashed everything you'd want from a good defender behind the plate, and he also gives the impression of a player who could hit well in the future.

Home/Pirates Prospects

Schedule