For the Pittsburgh Pirates, Tuesday could deliver one of the most bittersweet moments of the offseason. Brandon Lowe might become the franchise's first Silver Slugger winner in more than a decade just as the clock runs out on his qualifying-offer decision.
FanSided and Louisville Slugger will announce the winners of the 2026 Silver Slugger Awards on Nov. 17, the same day Lowe must decide whether to accept Pittsburgh's one-year, $23.15 million offer. Given the market for his services, declining it remains the likeliest outcome. So the Pirates could spend the day celebrating their most accomplished hitter while confronting the very real possibility of losing him.
Lowe deserves serious consideration to take home the hardware. The 32-year-old hit .260 with 35 home runs, 96 RBI and an .824 OPS in his first season in Pittsburgh. He led all MLB second basemen in homers and, when playing the position, also paced them in slugging percentage and OPS. His 33 home runs as a second baseman shattered the Pirates' previous positional record.
His lone competition is Milwaukee's Brice Turang, who presents a legitimate challenge. Turang hit .268 with a .366 on-base percentage, 21 homers and 100 RBI. He was an NL MVP finalist and helped the Brewers win the World Series. In fact, Turang already finished ahead of Lowe on the All-MLB team and beat out the competition for the NL Gold Glove at second base.
But the Silver Slugger is an offensive award, not a championship résumé contest. Turang reached base more consistently, but Lowe supplied the kind of middle-of-the-order power that few second basemen can match. He deserves this award.
We present to you: all 35 of Brandon Lowe's home runs from this season. 💣 pic.twitter.com/QO8zCc0MPK
— Pittsburgh Pirates (@Pirates) November 5, 2026
Brandon Lowe's potential Silver Slugger win would make Ben Cherington's toughest decision even harder
A win for Lowe would end an embarrassing drought for the Pirates, who haven't had a Silver Slugger winner since Andrew McCutchen in 2015. It would also underline an uncomfortable truth about Ben Cherington's roster construction: one of the most productive offensive players of his tenure arrived in a trade with just one guaranteed season remaining.
Lowe's success was supposed to represent a turning point. His bat helped Pittsburgh reach 82 wins, its first winning season since 2018, while his leadership and improved defense made him more than a one-dimensional rental. Instead, that success has made keeping him substantially more difficult.
The qualifying offer was an obvious move, but it's not a realistic long-term retention strategy. Lowe is widely expected to seek a multiyear contract, and interest from teams such as the Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees gives his representatives leverage. Pittsburgh can't simply assume that his positive experience with the organization will translate into a hometown discount.
Cherington has said he would welcome Lowe back and has described conversations with his camp as productive. The Pirates reportedly view retaining him as their preferred outcome. Those are encouraging signs, but encouraging signs don't hit 35 home runs.
There's also the risk of mistaking draft-pick compensation for an acceptable substitute. A pick would soften the blow of Lowe's departure, not replace the offense Pittsburgh would lose immediately.
The Pirates already have to build on a winning season without taking a step backward. Letting their best power hitter leave would create another major hole in a lineup that still needs upgrades elsewhere.
If Lowe wins Tuesday, Pittsburgh should celebrate him. But the award would make the question facing Cherington even harder to dodge: What exactly was the point of finally acquiring a Silver Slugger-caliber hitter if the Pirates can't find a way to keep him?
