Skip to main content

Ben Cherington's comment on Pirates pitching approach opens unexpected free agent opportunity

His top priority may not be what you think.
ByEmma Lingan
2026 MLB General Managers Meetings - Media Availability
2026 MLB General Managers Meetings - Media Availability | Sean M. Haffey/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates' starting rotation has been one of the biggest talking points of their offseason, and understandably so. But general manager Ben Cherington's latest comments, combined with new reporting about the team's pitching priorities, suggest the Pirates might be more interested in upgrading their bullpen than adding another starter.

According to Colin Beazley of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Pittsburgh is actively targeting left-handed pitching, with a particular emphasis on the relief market. The Pirates aren't ruling out a left-handed starter or even a swingman capable of filling both roles, but their reported focus on relievers is especially revealing.

Cherington has insisted that the Pirates won't limit themselves to improving at specific positions. Asked about potentially upgrading the rotation during the GM Meetings, he said, "If there's ways to make the team better through the rotation, then we're going to pursue that."

But keeping the door open to another starter isn't necessarily the same as making one the priority. And that distinction could open an unexpected avenue for Pittsburgh to make a meaningful free-agent addition without committing the kind of money typically required to secure an established starting pitcher.

Pirates' reported bullpen focus could change their offseason priorities

On paper, the Pirates already have five rotation spots effectively accounted for with Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler, Braxton Ashcraft and Mitch Keller. Keller, despite his disappointing 2026 campaign and season-ending injury, remains under contract for two more seasons.

There's certainly an argument for adding a veteran left-handed starter, particularly given Keller's uncertainty and the rotation's lack of balance. But signing one would also create questions about how Pittsburgh intends to distribute innings among its existing starters.

Adding a reliever presents no such complication. The Pirates already have an established late-inning foundation in Mason Montgomery and Luke Weaver, but Gregory Soto's departure into free agency leaves a significant opening. Brandon Eisert and Evan Sisk provide additional left-handed depth, though neither is an established high-leverage option.

A proven southpaw capable of handling the seventh or eighth inning would allow Pittsburgh to deploy Montgomery more strategically rather than relying on him to neutralize every difficult left-handed matchup. And perhaps most importantly, the Pirates could improve their bullpen without making a long-term commitment that complicates the rest of their offseason.

JoJo Romero stands out as a particularly logical target on the free-agent market. The former Cardinals and Brewers reliever has extensive experience pitching in high-leverage situations, including 77 holds over the past three seasons. He could provide the kind of dependable setup option Pittsburgh needs behind Montgomery.

Steven Okert is another possibility, having quietly established himself as an effective veteran reliever with Houston. Meanwhile, Tyler Alexander could appeal to the Pirates if they genuinely value the flexibility of a pitcher capable of handling multiple innings or making occasional starts.

Of course, re-signing Soto shouldn't be dismissed, either. He recorded 16 saves and a 3.63 ERA in 2026, and Pittsburgh already knows what he brings to the bullpen.

The problem is that established left-handed relief pitching isn't necessarily cheap. The market values premium southpaws aggressively, and Pittsburgh might find itself priced out of the most desirable options. But that doesn't eliminate the opportunity. It simply makes identifying the right tier of free agent even more important.

The Pirates finished 2026 with their first winning record since 2018, but their 82-80 finish also demonstrated how much work remains before they can seriously challenge the National League's contenders. Adding another starter could improve their pitching staff, as could upgrading a bullpen that already showed considerable improvement during the second half.

Cherington's willingness to explore both approaches is sensible. But if the Pirates' reported interest in left-handed relievers is any indication, their most consequential pitching addition this winter might not be someone who starts games.

It might be someone who helps them finish more of them.

Add us as a preferred source on Google