Brewers' World Series rally shows Pirates what smart baseball looks like

The most important play of the Milwaukee Brewers' historic World Series Game 3 victory over the Tampa Bay Rays wasn't a home run, a spectacular defensive play or even a base hit.

It was a replay challenge.

And for the Pittsburgh Pirates, it offered a perfect illustration of what general manager Ben Cherington has spent much of the past year preaching about the importance of playing smarter, more fundamentally sound baseball.

With two outs in the fifth inning Monday night, Milwaukee's William Contreras hit a ground ball to Rays third baseman Junior Caminero, who threw to second base for what appeared to be an inning-ending forceout of Christian Yelich.

Except Yelich had beaten the throw.

Brewers manager Pat Murphy challenged the call, replay confirmed that Yelich was safe, and Milwaukee suddenly had the bases loaded with two outs instead of heading back to the dugout.

What happened next was nothing short of historic. The Brewers strung together seven consecutive hits, scoring eight runs with two outs to turn a competitive 2-0 game into a 10-0 blowout. It was the most runs ever scored with two outs in a single inning of a World Series game, and Milwaukee cruised to a 10-1 victory to take a commanding 3-0 series lead.

Not one of those eight runs required a home run. Instead, the Brewers combined heads-up baserunning, an alert managerial decision and relentless situational hitting to produce one of the most remarkable innings in postseason history.

Sound familiar, Pirates fans?

Brewers' World Series success offers Don Kelly a blueprint for Pirates' next step

Cherington has repeatedly emphasized that the Pirates cannot simply rely on their most talented players to carry them to October. They need to execute the little things consistently, particularly when competing against teams with deeper rosters and significantly larger payrolls.

To Pittsburgh's credit, there was tangible improvement in that department during Don Kelly's first full season as manager. After going a miserable 25-35 in one-run games in 2025, the Pirates improved to 28-19 in those contests in 2026.

That's encouraging progress for a team that finished 82-80 and recorded its first winning season since 2018. But there's a significant difference between improving enough to win close regular-season games and executing at the level required to win a World Series.

The Brewers didn't simply benefit from a favorable replay review. Yelich's hustle made the challenge possible in the first place. Murphy and his staff recognized the opportunity to overturn the call, and the hitters capitalized instead of allowing the inning to fizzle. Each individual decision contributed to something much bigger, and that's precisely the kind of collective execution Pittsburgh needs to develop as its young core matures.

While improved performance in one-run games is promising, that statistic alone doesn't necessarily prove a team has mastered situational baseball. Bullpen performance, timely hitting and plain old luck can influence those results, too.

The Pirates need to demonstrate that their improvement is sustainable through better defensive execution, smarter baserunning, more disciplined approaches at the plate and sharper in-game decision-making.

None of that means Pittsburgh can neglect its obvious roster needs this offseason. The Brewers have plenty of talent, and even the best managerial decisions mean little without players capable of capitalizing on them. But Milwaukee is also demonstrating that championship-caliber baseball requires more than simply assembling an impressive collection of individual players.

It requires preparation, accountability and an understanding that seemingly insignificant moments can determine the outcome of an entire season. Kelly deserves credit for the progress Pittsburgh made in 2026. Now the challenge is establishing a standard of execution that holds up when the pressure increases.

Because the difference between a team that finishes just above .500 and one competing for a World Series championship isn't always measured in payroll dollars or individual statistics. Sometimes, it's measured in the few inches separating a runner's foot from a force out at second base — and whether an entire organization is prepared to recognize and capitalize on the opportunity.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow