Bryan Reynolds just emphasized a Pirates problem this struggling lineup can’t survive

The Pittsburgh Pirates can survive cold stretches at the plate. Most teams do over a 162-game season.

What they can’t survive is pairing inconsistent offense with sloppy defense. And on Thursday afternoon at PNC Park, Bryan Reynolds unintentionally highlighted exactly why this recent skid has started to spiral.

Reynolds was not charged with an error in the disastrous eighth inning of the Pirates’ 10-5 loss to the St. Louis Cardinals, but everyone watching understood the importance of the play he didn’t make. Masyn Winn ripped a liner directly toward Reynolds in right field that could have been the first out of the inning. Instead, the ball dropped in front of him, the inning snowballed, and the Cardinals immediately turned a one-run game into a blowout.

Afterward, Reynolds explained that the stadium lights impacted his vision on the play. Don Kelly backed him up, suggesting the lighting played a major factor. Fair enough. Every outfielder loses a ball occasionally. It happens.

But that’s almost beside the point. The larger issue is that this Pirates team simply is not built to give away outs defensively, especially right now.

Pirates can't afford to ignore the fact that their defense is costing them games

Coming into Thursday, Pittsburgh’s outfield defense already ranked among the worst in the National League with minus-4 Outs Above Average. Only the Philadelphia Phillies had been worse in the NL. When your offense is struggling to consistently score runs, those extra outs become devastating.

The Pirates had actually clawed their way back into the game moments earlier thanks to another big swing from Brandon Lowe, whose home run cut the deficit to one and briefly shifted momentum back toward Pittsburgh.

But instead of building off that spark, the Pirates immediately unraveled. Nathan Church delivered a two-run double. Alec Burleson followed with a two-run single. Jordan Walker added another RBI knock for good measure.

The Cardinals exposed every weakness the Pirates have spent the opening month kof the season trying to mask. The starting pitching faltered. The bullpen cracked in key moments. The defense failed to make routine plays. And perhaps most concerning of all, the offense remained incapable of consistently punishing mistakes. That combination is toxic.

The Pirates entered this homestand looking like a team that might finally be turning the corner after an aggressive offseason. Instead, they leave April at 16-16, riding a five-game losing streak and sitting in last place in what suddenly looks like baseball’s toughest division.

To be clear, there is still plenty of time left in the season. Nobody should be burying the Pirates on May 1. But the margin for error already feels painfully thin.

This lineup does not have the firepower to overcome defensive lapses every night. They aren’t the Dodgers or Yankees, capable of erasing mistakes with three swings of the bat. The Pirates were supposed to win with pitching, clean defense, athleticism and timely offense.

Lately, they haven’t done any of those things well. And if that doesn’t change quickly against a first-place Cincinnati Reds team coming to town, this rough week could start looking a lot more like the beginning of a genuine problem than just an early-season slump.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow