Bryan Reynolds' latest nomination validates Pirates' decision to extend him

Back in the 2023 offseason, the Pirates began an effort to extend their star outfielder, Bryan Reynolds, to a long-term contract. When the two sides were unable to make the requisite amount of progress, Reynolds reportedly requested a trade, throwing his future in Pittsburgh into question.

Somehow, some way, both sides worked out a deal through all the noise, agreeing to the largest contract in team history (an indictment of Bob Nutting, but still) by the end of April 2023.

While Reynolds' positional future may still be up for debate, he's been a remarkably consistent performer over the past two seasons. As 2024 ends, Reynolds has received another accolade that proves the Pirates were wise to extend the relationship.

Pirates' star Bryan Reynolds named a finalist for the utility Silver Slugger award

Reynolds' 2024 season was fairly solid, which placed him in the running for this award. He was named an All-Star for the second time in his career.

Last season, Reynolds had an OPS of .791 with 24 home runs, driving in 88. His 29 doubles and three triples contributed to his slugging percentage of .447. He also had an above average wRC+ of 118 and his batting average finished at .275. If it weren't for his defense, his fWAR would be higher, but the number still sits at 2.1. This could be improved upon, but certainly isn't bad.

It is strange that Reynolds was labeled as a utility player, as he played 118 games in left field, 23 at designated hitter, and 22 in right field.

The other finalists for the utility spot are Luis Arraez of the Padres, Mookie Betts of the Dodgers, and Jake Burger of the Marlins. Within this group, Reynolds does have a very solid chance of winning. Betts had a great year, but only played in 116 games. Arraez had a batting average over .300 and a strikeout percentage below 5%. Burger had 29 homers, but aside from that, he is not as deserving of the award as these other candidates.

Overall, Reynolds being named a finalist for the award should make fans feel a lot better about the contract extension. Money is often tight in Pittsburgh, which makes this much more important for the franchise.