The qualifying offer is a funny thing. The reasons why a team would tag a player with it can be very different, while a player's motivations for accepting or declining can vary wildly as well. This is the story for the Pittsburgh Pirates with Brandon Lowe, and the contrast with the New York Yankees and former Pirate David Bednar proves this rule.
Unsurprisingly, Lowe turned down the Pirates' $23.15 million offer, while Bednar decided to accept the same sum from the Yankees. The logic behind both clubs using the QO was different from the beginning, and these two players came to the opposite conclusions for nuanced reasons.
Sometimes teams hit free agents that they have no intention of re-signing with the qualifying offer because they know it will be rejected, and they can collect some draft capital from their departure. That wasn't the motivation for either the Pirates or the Yankees in these two instances, though.
The Pirates have every intention of trying to re-sign Lowe, so the QO gambit was more about driving down his price tag. The draft pick compensation might soften the blow a bit should they lose him, but that's not the goal.
New York offered Bednar the one-year, $23.15 option because they hoped he'd accept it. They thought there was a good chance that he would, and they were right. The reason being, as a closer, $23.15 million makes Bednar one of the highest-paid closers by AAV. He can re-enter the market next offseason unencumbered, and if he pitches as he did in 2026, he'll land a very lucrative long-term deal. Overall, he'll likely make more money this way than if he had turned it down and secured a multi-year contract now.
Lowe's calculus is different. $23.15 million is a nice salary, but it's likely not much more than what he could receive on a multi-year contract now. The enhanced earning potential argument doesn't apply to him. In fact, he's likely only hurt by it.
While no one expects Lowe's production to fall off a cliff any time soon, his value is at an all-time high in part due to an outlier year in the field. For his career, he's been a negative defender, and if he were to come back to earth with the glove, the QO would cost him money next winter. Related to that, he'll be 33 in July, meaning that age will soon be a greater factor in both the number of years and dollars that he'll receive.
BRANDON LOWE WINS IT FOR THE PIRATES 🏴☠️🔥 pic.twitter.com/LYsf23awly
— SportsNet Pittsburgh (@SNPittsburgh) August 19, 2026
Brandon Lowe accepting the qualifying offer was unlikely, but the logic behind offering it still stands
Pittsburgh would have jumped for joy had Lowe surprised everyone and accepted the qualifying offer. $23.15 million is hefty no matter how you slice it, but for just one year, even the Pirates can swallow the sum with relative ease.
Now, though, they're looking for it to have its desired impact — driving down Lowe's price on a multi-year deal to something that they can afford. There's a decent shot that it works. Second base is the deepest position player group in the free-agent class, and guys like Jazz Chisholm Jr., Gleyber Torres, and Luis Arraez all present somewhat comparable value despite drastically different skill sets.
No one in that trio has the QO penalty attached, so teams might be more willing to go after a slightly worse option in order to save the draft pick.
That gives the Pirates something of a win-win situation. If everything works as intended, they'll get Lowe back at a slight discount. If things get out of hand, they'll get a higher draft pick back should he exceed their budget.
A draft pick is a pittance compared to what Lowe meant to the team this year, but if things break the way Pittsburgh hopes, it will be a massive win to bring such a key cog back while saving a few dollars in the process.
