It goes without saying at this point, but the Pittsburgh Pirates' ideal offseason includes a reunion with Brandon Lowe. Their replacement options are less than ideal, with no other second baseman in free agency capable of providing the same combination of power and elite defense that the 32-year-old did in 2026.
Of course, the fact that Lowe remains available in mid-November — mere weeks away from the likely start of a lockout — isn't the best sign that he's planning to return to Pittsburgh. If the Bucs were going to re-sign him, their best chance to do so was before he ever reached the open market; now, he can negotiate an exorbitant deal with any team willing to pay his price.
If he is going to leave, that's the exact result we all need to hope for: A deal so big that the Pirates never could have matched it.
Pirates will reap massive draft benefits if Brandon Lowe's next contract is worth $50 million or more
One thing working in the Pirates' favor in the Lowe sweepstakes is the fact that he's attached to the qualifying offer. Although he declined the offer as expected, any other team that signs him will now have to forfeit draft picks and international bonus pool money to Pittsburgh.
Brandon Lowe has told the Pirates he intends to decline the qualifying offer. @jonmorosi had it first
— Alex Stumpf (@AlexJStumpf) November 17, 2026
The two sides can still negotiate a different contract. If he signs elsewhere, the Pirates will get a draft pick
While that could drive his market down into the Pirates' comfort zone, the second-best possible outcome is that another team throws caution to the wind and hands Lowe a sizable long-term contract. If the next deal he signs is worth $50 million or more, the Bucs will get a compensatory draft pick directly after the first round of the 2027 MLB Draft. If it's worth less than that threshold, the pick will come about 40 selections later, just before the start of the third round.
That's obviously a big gap, one that comes with money-related consequences as well since the assigned bonus slots for late first-round picks is far larger than that of early third-rounders. If the Pirates want some more freedom with their ability to hand out over-slot deals to their next draft class, Lowe leaving would grant it.
And there's some good news to report on this front: Jake Bauers just landed a $58 million contract despite being attached to the QO, and he doesn't have half the track record that Lowe does. There's a very good chance that, if the second baseman leaves, the Bucs will be handsomely rewarded for his departure.
