Skip to main content

Giants' latest trade rumor gives Pirates an intriguing answer to their biggest lineup flaw

The perfect fit could come at a painful cost.
ByEmma Lingan
Los Angeles Angels v San Francisco Giants
Los Angeles Angels v San Francisco Giants | San Francisco Giants/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates desperately need more right-handed power. The San Francisco Giants apparently have some to spare. And a potential trade between the two teams could present Ben Cherington with one of his most interesting offseason dilemmas yet.

According to ESPN's Jeff Passan, the Giants have floated infielder Casey Schmitt in trade discussions as they search for pitching upgrades. For a Pirates team looking to address its glaring struggles against left-handed pitching, Schmitt checks almost every box.

The 27-year-old enjoyed a breakout 2026 campaign, batting .271/.301/.483 with 21 home runs and 55 RBI in just 98 games. More importantly for Pittsburgh, he hit .314 with an .820 OPS against left-handed pitching.

Considering the Pirates batted an MLB-worst .229/.300/.359 against southpaws last season, it's difficult to imagine a more obvious offensive fit.

Schmitt also offers defensive versatility, having played third base, second base and other positions throughout his career. That flexibility would be particularly valuable for a Pittsburgh club still sorting through its infield configuration, especially with Brandon Lowe's future uncertain.

But the Giants were to consider trading Schmitt, they would be looking for pitching in return — and that could force Cherington to make an uncomfortable decision.

Would the Pirates sacrifice Carmen Mlodzinski to acquire Casey Schmitt?

Carmen Mlodzinski might be one of Pittsburgh's most intriguing potential trade chips. The 27-year-old posted a 3.95 ERA across 123 innings in 2026, demonstrating an ability to contribute both as a starter and out of the bullpen. He's also under affordable team control and has made it clear that he would prefer an opportunity to establish himself as a full-time starter. That could make him attractive to a Giants organization actively seeking rotation help.

From Pittsburgh's perspective, however, trading Mlodzinski wouldn't be quite as straightforward as moving a surplus reliever. The Pirates have Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler and Braxton Ashcraft among their potential rotation options, but they've also spent much of the offseason emphasizing pitching depth. Dealing Mlodzinski would eliminate one of their more versatile insurance policies, especially with Mitch Keller coming off an injury-shortened, disappointing season.

It's also highly unlikely San Francisco would consider Mlodzinski sufficient compensation. The Giants are reportedly pursuing starting pitching, and while Mlodzinski has experience in that role, his most effective work has often come out of the bullpen. They could demand a more established starter or a younger pitching prospect with greater rotation upside.

Schmitt isn't without risk himself, as a torn meniscus in his left knee required surgery and prematurely ended his breakout season in July. Although he was subsequently cleared for a normal offseason, Pittsburgh would need to feel confident that his health won't compromise his production or defensive versatility.

Still, Schmitt has three seasons of team control remaining, meaning Pittsburgh wouldn't be sacrificing valuable pitching depth for another potential one-year rental.

Cherington has spent years accumulating young pitching while searching for sustainable offensive improvement. At some point, that pitching depth needs to become a resource the Pirates are willing to use, rather than something they're perpetually afraid to sacrifice.

Schmitt represents precisely the kind of offensive upgrade Pittsburgh should be exploring: young, affordable, versatile and capable of addressing an unmistakable lineup weakness. The Pirates shouldn't automatically surrender Mlodzinski or a premium pitching prospect to get him, but they also shouldn't dismiss the possibility simply because it would cost them something valuable.

After all, the entire point of building organizational depth is eventually being able to use it to make the major league team better. Schmitt might be worth that sacrifice. The question is whether Cherington is willing to find out.

Add us as a preferred source on Google