The Pittsburgh Pirates need to add right-handed balance to the starting lineup and would be wise to shore up the third base situation after Nick Gonzales's defensive struggles in 2026. What if they could roll up both problems into one solution?
That's the idea that Josh Harrison recently put forth on the Bucco Territory Podcast. The former Pirates second baseman suggested that Pittsburgh go out in the trade market and target a Houston Astros infielder to fill in these gaps. No, he's not advocating for the answer you're thinking of, Isaac Paredes, who doesn't fit well in PNC Park. Instead, the answer Harrison proposed is swinging a trade for shortstop Jeremy Peña and inserting him at the hot corner.
"I look at the other intangibles. Sprint speed — this Pirates team is a team that we talk about team speed. [Peña] adds that dynamic, and a guy that not only adds that dynamic, but has also played on some teams that have gone deep into the playoffs. And when you're a team that is, you know, on the brink of that, you want to add players that have been to where you're trying to get," Harrison said.
Trading for Jeremy Pena and playing him at 3B would not only bring even more speed to the lineup, it would bring someone who has won before
— Bucco Territory (@BuccoTerritory) November 12, 2026
"You want to add players that have been to where you're trying to get" pic.twitter.com/mfQsz4jBDH
As Harrison states, Peña has extensive postseason experience from playing in Houston, including becoming the first rookie in history to win a World Series MVP award during the Astros' 2022 championship run. He was also named ALCS MVP that same year.
That clutch gene is valuable, but perhaps even more so would be the wisdom that he can impart to the Pirates youngsters, should the club make an appearance in October 2027. As for the speed factor, Peña's 29.3 feet per second sprint speed in 2026 was a 93rd percentile mark. While he's never stolen more than 20 bases in a single season and put up only 12 steals in 2026, that's more a function of Houston's conservative baserunning than an indictment of his ability to translate that speed to actual impact.
Putting him together with some of the other speedsters that the Pirates have, namely Konnor Griffin, Oneil Cruz, and Jake Mangum, gives the team another dynamic to keep teams on their toes beyond just power. Peña is also a contact-oriented bat, slashing .277/.325/.477 in 2026, and .304/.363/.477 in 2025. That would be another welcome addition to the Pittsburgh lineup, and the 20-homer pop he provides, along with that contact, makes him a truly multi-dimensional hitter.
Jeremy Peña would make a lot of sense for the Pirates, but there's an obstacle
The Pirates and Astros match up relatively well for a trade. Houston has an abundance of infielders and needs cost-controlled pitching. The Pirates have cost-controlled pitching to offer up, and the two sides have made deals before.
However, there's a new regime in Houston, so the past relationship doesn't really count. On top of that, while the Astros need to move an infielder, they'd prefer to trade one of their players at the corners, like Paredes or first baseman Christian Walker.
Those hurdles can be smoothed out, but there's a greater risk. Peña is set to become a free agent at the end of the 2027 season, which in normal times would be helpful in terms of decreasing the cost of acquisition, but with the looming lockout potentially threatening games being played next season, finding an appropriate value could be difficult. Houston won't give him away for free, but the Pirates would be wise not to overpay, given the uncertainty that they'd play all 162 contests next year.
The way to hedge would be to extend Peña. That's another sticking point, though. The 29-year-old has rejected extension overtures from the Astros in the past, and that was before switching agents and hiring Scott Boras, who loves to take his clients to the open market.
This isn't to say that Peña isn't a worthwhile pursuit, or that the two sides can't come to a deal. The fact of the matter is that Peña would bring a lot of value to the Pirates; they'd just need to proceed with caution to avoid trading too many future assets for a player who might not play a full season in 2027 and could bolt afterwards. If the Astros are reasonable, this would become a slam dunk.
