The old adage that you can never have too much pitching is one of the truer clichés in all of sports. It's certainly true for the Pittsburgh Pirates, who have an impressive collection of young starting pitchers. Paul Skenes, Braxton Ashcraft, Jared Jones, and Bubba Chandler are all hurlers that any team in the league would love to have, but those four alone aren't enough.
Adding to the group is a critical need this offseason. Ben Cherington might want to convince you that Mitch Keller can be a key cog, but a backup plan or two is needed at the very least. After all, Keller missed significant time with a teres major muscle injury, and admitted that he never felt right all season.
Jones just came back from internal brace surgery to repair a torn UCL, and Ashcraft has a lengthy injury history. Skenes and Chandler have been unscathed, but as these other examples prove, all pitchers are injury risks to an extent.
The Washington Nationals might have just gifted Pittsburgh a high-upside depth option when they decided to DFA 2023 All-Star Josiah Gray. Gray was well-regarded as a young player, being a key part of two blockbuster trades: first getting dealt from the Reds to the Dodgers in a package for Yasiel Puig, Matt Kemp, Alex Wood, and Kyle Farmer in 2018, and then from the Dodgers to the Nationals as part of the deal that shipped Max Scherzer and Trea Turner to LA in 2021.
Josiah Gray would be a worthwhile Pirates pickup, but he can't be their only rotation addition
Obviously, Gray's journey from top prospect to All-Star to offseason roster casualty means that something went wrong along the way. The right-hander made just two starts in 2024 before succumbing to an elbow injury and undergoing Tommy John surgery. He'd miss all of 2025 as a result. Then, while working his way back this year, he suffered a right flexor strain that held him out until September. His season consisted of just three relief appearances.
This brings him to an inflection point. He either moves forward healthy and gets back on track, or he proves that injuries are a fact of life for him and can never be counted on. The Pirates would be wise to take a flier on his talent and find out, but they cannot be fooled into believing that he can be counted upon as a solution.
Josiah Gray RHP is an arm I think a lot of teams should be interested in. Lot of clay at 28 y/o. He just needs to pitch
— Mikey O’Connor (@OCBaseball814) November 17, 2026
3 fastball approach helps him mix to both sides. His low release & low extension help create good angles for his 92-93 mph FF. The cutter was great vs LHH in… https://t.co/YntZZ9rsvd
So, no, trading Mitch Keller and replacing him with a much cheaper Gray isn't a viable solution. However, giving Gray a shot on a minor league deal and using him as the sixth or seventh starter or a potential long man is the way to go.
The "big" addition to the rotation must be a veteran left-handed starter who can either replace Keller or supplement what Pittsburgh already has while providing a different look from the sea of right-handed power arms that anchor the unit. Gray has no bearing on that.
So Ben Cherington should definitely kick the tires on Gray, but by no means can the Pirates count on him as a real solution. If he rises to his previous heights, they'll look like geniuses. If he flops, there's no risk unless they don't prepare properly.
