Pirates' Brandon Lowe nightmare just got a very real December deadline

The Pittsburgh Pirates' top offseason priority will be finding a way to retain star second baseman Brandon Lowe. Bringing Lowe back is far from the club's only need. The Pirates also need to add a left-handed starter, fortify the bullpen, come up with a right-handed slugger, and improve their depth. With that said, Lowe is the most important and most expensive decision that Pittsburgh will have to make.

In a normal offseason, the blueprint would be clear. Hit Lowe with the qualifying offer, and hope that the combination of the draft pick compensation that carries plus his age (Lowe will turn 33 next July) makes him a less appealing option to other second-base-needy teams. After a while, his price would come down, and the Pirates could then bring him back on a contract that is relatively reasonable.

This all seems to be set up to work perfectly. There are three other top second basemen on the market. Gleyber Torres is ineligible for the qualifying offer due to him accepting it last offseason. That will move him up some clubs' boards. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is unlikely to get the QO from the Yankees after an up-and-down 2026 that ended with a hellish performance in the playoffs. Talent-wise, he's the most comparable to Lowe, though, and is also nearly four years younger than Lowe.

Finally, there's Luis Arraez, who is also unlikely to get the qualifying offer from the Philadelphia Phillies. Arraez isn't everyone's cup of tea, as evidenced by the series of one-year deals he's been forced to sign over the years, but as the Tampa Bay Rays and Milwaukee Brewers continue to prove that contact skills reign supreme in October, he could suddenly find himself in high demand.

With all that in mind, it seems like all the Pirates would need is time. Time to wait out the market, let Lowe get desperate, and finally, when the moment is right, they can swoop in with a reasonable contract and capitalize on the fact that he enjoyed his time here. Unfortunately, time is not something Pittsburgh will have to work with.

Time will not be on the Pirates' side when it comes to negotiations with Brandon Lowe

MLB released a memo to clubs outlining important dates and practices regarding a potential lockout. If the league does not come to an agreement with the Players' Association before the expiration of the current Collective Bargaining Agreement on December 1, that date will serve as the cutoff point for clubs to make transactions this winter until the two sides can come to a deal on a new CBA.

So while we laid out how the Pirates, in a typical offseason, could use the qualifying offer and market landscape to wait out Lowe, that option will not be available to them.

What likely happens is that we see a feeding frenzy, as deep-pocketed contenders throw money around to secure solutions to their needs before a transaction moratorium begins. Contracts signed during this period will likely be grandfathered in and exempted from any new restrictions a future CBA places on spending.

That means, if Pittsburgh tries to play the waiting game with Lowe in hopes that draft pick compensation via the qualifying offer will scare other clubs off, it could put itself in a dangerous predicament.

While the other three second basemen mentioned are above-average options, Lowe is on a tier of his own, so a desperate contender could throw caution to the wind and snatch him up. On top of that, the fast-moving nature of the offseason could leave the Pirates as the odd man out in the game of musical chairs, without a second baseman when the music stops, as Torres, Chisholm Jr., and Arraez all find homes quickly.

So, the Pirates have to come to the harsh realization that if they want Lowe, they have to be willing to pay top dollar. If they aren't willing to meet his price, they need to be willing to pivot quickly, or else they risk being left out in the cold.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow