Pirates’ Braxton Ashcraft workload gamble just blew up at the worst possible time

The Pittsburgh Pirates desperately needed Braxton Ashcraft for the final three weeks of the season. Instead, after asking more of his right arm than ever before, they’re left hoping they haven’t seen the last of him in 2026.

Ashcraft was placed on the 15-day injured list Thursday with right arm discomfort, retroactive to Sept. 7. Manager Don Kelly said Ashcraft raised concerns after his start Saturday against the Los Angeles Angels. The early indication is that the injury doesn't appear structural, although testing is continuing.

That qualifies as relatively encouraging news, but it doesn't make the situation any less frustrating. Because while nobody can definitively connect Ashcraft's current discomfort to his workload, the Pirates were unquestionably playing with fire.

Ashcraft threw 118 combined innings between Triple-A Indianapolis and Pittsburgh in 2025: 48.1 in the minors and another 69.2 in the majors. This year, he reached 165.1 innings before landing on the IL. That's an increase of more than 47 innings — roughly 40 percent — from one season to the next.

And this wasn't a pitcher with some extensive 150- or 180-inning foundation earlier in his career. Ashcraft threw only 73 innings in 2024 and 52.2 in 2023. He missed the entire 2022 season recovering from Tommy John surgery after undergoing the procedure in 2021.

Pirates’ handling of Braxton Ashcraft workload deserves scrutiny after IL move

The Pirates knew Ashcraft's history. They knew his previous workloads. They also knew how valuable he had become. Yet they kept pushing. It's understandable why.

Ashcraft has been phenomenal, going 14-6 with a 3.65 ERA, 173 strikeouts against only 35 walks and a 1.09 WHIP over 28 starts. He earned his first All-Star selection and developed from an intriguing young arm into one of the most important pitchers on Pittsburgh's roster.

But protecting young pitching sometimes requires making uncomfortable decisions before the pitcher gives you a reason to make them.

Pittsburgh could have occasionally skipped Ashcraft, used a six-man rotation, or looked for opportunities during the summer to manufacture additional rest. Instead, his innings kept piling up.

Now the Pirates are fighting for their postseason lives with Mitch Keller already done for the season and Ashcraft joining him on the IL. That leaves Paul Skenes, Bubba Chandler and Jared Jones as their only healthy established starters.

Maybe Ashcraft's arm discomfort ultimately proves minor. Maybe he's back before the regular season ends. But the larger concern won't disappear.

Pirates increased the workload of a pitcher with an extensive injury history by more than 40 percent while asking him to carry one of the heaviest burdens of his career.

They gambled that Ashcraft's arm would hold up. At the absolute worst possible time, that gamble finally looks dangerous.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow