Pirates' former top draft pick Termarr Johnson is facing an increasingly bleak road back to relevance

There was a time when Termarr Johnson was supposed to be one of the cornerstones of the Pittsburgh Pirates' future. Now, it's becoming increasingly difficult to figure out where he fits into that future at all.

The Pirates selected Johnson with the No. 4 overall pick in the 2022 MLB Draft, investing more than $7 million in a high school infielder widely regarded as one of the most gifted pure hitters in his draft class. He was supposed to become a foundational offensive piece for an organization desperately searching for young, controllable talent.

Four years later, Johnson's development has stalled, his prospect stock has plummeted, and a devastating knee injury has made an already uncertain future even more complicated.

Johnson underwent surgery in August after tearing his ACL and LCL while playing for Triple-A Indianapolis. The injury ended a disappointing season in which the 22-year-old slashed just .199/.336/.319 with eight home runs and 37 RBIs across 96 games.

Those numbers would have been concerning enough on their own. For a player whose greatest selling point was supposed to be his exceptional hitting ability, a .199 batting average at Triple-A represents a particularly troubling development.

And while Johnson's plate discipline remains a strength — he drew 68 walks in 2026 — his inability to consistently produce hits or generate meaningful power has raised legitimate questions about his offensive ceiling.

Termarr Johnson's place in Pirates' future looks increasingly uncertain

Perhaps the most discouraging part of Johnson's situation is how dramatically the organization's prospect hierarchy has changed around him.

Konnor Griffin, selected two years after Johnson, has already reached the major leagues and established himself as Pittsburgh's shortstop of the future. Griffin's rapid ascent has provided the Pirates with exactly the kind of young, dynamic position player they hoped Johnson would become.

Meanwhile, Murf Gray has emerged as another exciting young infielder. The 2025 draft pick hit 32 home runs across three minor league levels in 2026 and climbed to No. 4 in MLB Pipeline's organizational prospect rankings. Other young hitters, including Edward Florentino and Wyatt Sanford, have also generated excitement about Pittsburgh's next wave of offensive talent.

Brandon Lowe's impending free agency could create an opportunity at second base, Johnson's projected long-term position. But Nick Gonzales and Jared Triolo are already major league options, and Pittsburgh has other young infielders competing for future opportunities.

Johnson isn't necessarily blocked by one particular player. He's facing an increasingly crowded organizational picture in which several other players have done more to establish themselves as legitimate long-term solutions.

And now, instead of spending the offseason addressing the offensive shortcomings that plagued his 2026 campaign, Johnson must prioritize recovering from major knee surgery. His return to the field, whenever that comes, will be about rebuilding physically before he can focus on rebuilding his prospect status.

None of this means Johnson's career is over. He's only 22, and his patience at the plate and underlying offensive tools provide legitimate reasons to believe there's still untapped potential. But potential alone can only carry a prospect so far.

The Pirates have spent years waiting for Johnson to develop into the impact hitter they envisioned when they drafted him fourth overall. Meanwhile, younger prospects have climbed through the system, reached the majors and moved ahead of him in the organization's long-term plans.

Johnson still has time to change that narrative. But the uncomfortable reality is that Pittsburgh's future is taking shape without him, and the window to prove he belongs in it is becoming considerably narrower.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow