Pirates give Alika Williams a fresh start while chasing pitching upside

The Pittsburgh Pirates did right by Alika Williams. They also did something they have to keep doing if they want to maximize the margins of their roster: turn blocked depth into pitching upside.

Pittsburgh traded Williams to the Athletics on Saturday for 22-year-old right-hander Kyle Robinson, a move that makes sense for both sides. Oakland needed a shortstop after Jacob Wilson landed on the injured list with a dislocated left shoulder and subluxation. The Pirates had a defense-first middle infielder with major-league experience, but no obvious path back to Pittsburgh.

Williams’ glove has never been the question. He can play shortstop. He can handle second base. He can give a team competent, reliable infield defense, which is exactly why the A’s had reason to call. But in Pittsburgh, the roster math had turned against him. Konnor Griffin’s arrival changed the middle-infield picture. Jared Triolo’s versatility and Gold Glove-caliber defense made it even harder to envision a clean opening. Nick Gonzales’ emergence has also helped crowd the infield conversation.

Even with Williams hitting .317/.385/.467 at Triple-A Indianapolis, he was still waiting on an opportunity that may not have come. So instead of letting him sit in the minors as insurance, the Pirates gave him a fresh start with a team that can actually use him. Williams is 27, no longer a prospect, and still young enough to carve out a real role if he gets the right opportunity. Oakland can offer him the immediacy that Pittsburgh could not.

Pirates turn crowded infield picture into another intriguing young arm

For the Pirates, the return is a bet on traits. Robinson is not a finished product. His 3.62 ERA and 1.35 WHIP at High-A Lansing come with the obvious concern of 13 walks in 27-plus innings. Command will determine whether he becomes a legitimate pitching prospect or organizational depth.

But he is also 6-foot-6, 225 pounds, recently drafted and still early in his professional development. The Pirates may not be acquiring certainty here, but they are acquiring a pitcher with size, starter experience and room to grow. For a player who was blocked from their major-league roster, that is a perfectly reasonable gamble.

This is the kind of small move that will not define a season, but it does reflect good process. The Pirates identified a player who deserved a better opportunity elsewhere and converted him into a young arm with some upside.

Williams gets a clearer path. The Pirates get another pitching lottery ticket. That is a trade both sides should be comfortable making.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow