Skip to main content

Pirates’ latest non-tender intel suggests one tough roster decision is already settled

Pittsburgh has enough holes to fill without creating another one.
ByEmma Lingan
Pittsburgh Pirates v Miami Marlins
Pittsburgh Pirates v Miami Marlins | Rich Storry/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates have plenty of difficult roster decisions ahead of them this offseason, but one that initially appeared more complicated than it should have been may already be settled.

According to a November 13 report from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, a source familiar with the team's plans believes the majority — potentially all — of Pittsburgh's 11 arbitration-eligible players will receive contract offers ahead of Friday's non-tender deadline. The lone potential exception appears to be outfielder Akil Baddoo, whom the Pirates claimed off waivers from the Milwaukee Brewers earlier this month.

That suggests the Pirates are leaning toward retaining utility infielder Jared Triolo, whose future had become a subject of some speculation despite his defensive credentials. And frankly, that would be the right call.

Pirates' reported arbitration plans offer encouraging sign for Jared Triolo's future

Triolo's name had surfaced as a potential non-tender consideration because of his limited offensive production and the organization's need to manage its payroll.

MLB Trade Rumors projected him to earn approximately $1.8 million through arbitration in 2027. For a team facing substantial salary increases elsewhere on the roster, even relatively modest financial commitments deserve consideration.

Triolo certainly didn't make the decision easy with his bat. The 28-year-old finished the 2026 season hitting just .238/.307/.302 with a .609 OPS. His offensive limitations are difficult to ignore, particularly for a Pirates team that desperately needs to build on the improvements it made at the plate this season.

But reducing Triolo's value to his offensive numbers ignores what makes him an important piece of Pittsburgh's roster. He won the National League Gold Glove Award as a utility player in 2024 and was a finalist for the honor again in 2026. He finished this past season with five defensive runs saved while providing reliable coverage at shortstop, third base and several other positions.

Triolo's versatility proved especially valuable when Konnor Griffin missed time with injuries, allowing the Pirates to maintain competent defensive play at shortstop without completely reshuffling their infield. That's not a particularly glamorous contribution, but it's one the Pirates shouldn't take for granted.

Consider the alternative. Nick Gonzales enjoyed an impressive offensive season, hitting .303, but finished with minus-15 defensive runs saved at third base. Pittsburgh already has questions about where Gonzales fits defensively in 2027, and Griffin's injury history underscores the importance of having dependable insurance behind him.

Removing Triolo from the equation would only create another unnecessary problem.

There's also an important distinction between retaining Triolo and committing to him as an everyday starter. The Pirates can acknowledge his offensive shortcomings while recognizing that a Gold Glove-caliber utility defender has legitimate value off the bench. At a projected $1.8 million, keeping that insurance hardly qualifies as an unreasonable investment.

The Pirates have repeatedly emphasized improving their roster rather than simply maintaining the status quo. But improvement doesn't require discarding every imperfect player, especially when replacing his most valuable skills could prove more difficult than anticipated.

If Ben Cherington intends to build a more complete, defensively responsible team around Pittsburgh's young pitching staff, retaining an affordable and versatile defender should be among his easier decisions.

The Pirates have enough legitimate holes to address this offseason. Creating another one merely to save $1.8 million would be a questionable use of their supposed financial flexibility.

Keeping Triolo won't transform the roster. But it would prevent Cherington from making his job unnecessarily harder.

Add us as a preferred source on Google