Skip to main content

Pirates Rumors: Contender's growing Brandon Lowe interest gives Ben Cherington a familiar nightmare

Not again...
ByEmma Lingan
MLB: AUG 18 Tigers at Pirates
MLB: AUG 18 Tigers at Pirates | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates already know what it's like to watch one of their best players end up in pinstripes. Now, the New York Yankees could be positioning themselves to add another.

After acquiring former Pirates closer David Bednar at the 2025 trade deadline, the Yankees have emerged as a potential landing spot for free-agent second baseman Brandon Lowe. According to Jon Morosi of MLB Network, Lowe is drawing interest from American League East clubs, with New York among the potential fits.

The speculation gained additional traction Sunday when MLB.com's Yankees coverage made a compelling case for Lowe as a replacement for free agent Jazz Chisholm Jr. New York declined to extend Chisholm a qualifying offer, leaving an opening at second base that Lowe could fill rather convincingly.

Lowe was arguably Pittsburgh's most important position player in 2026, hitting .260 with 35 home runs, 96 RBI and an .824 OPS while transforming himself into a Gold Glove finalist. His production was instrumental in helping the Pirates secure their first winning season since 2018.

Now, after just one season in Pittsburgh, he could be headed for a considerably bigger stage.

Yankees' Brandon Lowe connection exposes uncomfortable reality for Pirates

The Yankees have a legitimate need at second base, and Lowe's left-handed power profiles exceptionally well at Yankee Stadium. Of his 35 home runs in 2026, 32 were hit to right field. According to Statcast, Lowe's expected home run total would have been 39 had he played every game at Yankee Stadium.

Unlike Pittsburgh, New York has the financial flexibility to turn that interest into a competitive multiyear offer without necessarily making Lowe the centerpiece of its entire offseason. That's where Ben Cherington's familiar nightmare begins.

The Pirates have repeatedly emphasized their desire to bring Lowe back. At last week's GM Meetings, Cherington acknowledged that discussions with Lowe and his representatives were ongoing and described their relationship positively. But goodwill doesn't pay the difference between competing contract offers.

Lowe is 32 years old and coming off one of the best seasons of his career. This could be his final opportunity to secure a substantial long-term contract, and nobody should expect him to sacrifice millions of dollars simply because he enjoyed his time in Pittsburgh.

The Pirates extended Lowe a one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer, which he has until Tuesday, Nov. 17, to accept or decline. That was an important first step, but it was also the bare minimum for an organization that claims retaining him is a priority.

Cherington can't reasonably expect the qualifying offer, positive clubhouse relationships and vague assurances about the team's competitive future to outweigh a substantially better financial commitment elsewhere — especially when that commitment could come from a perennial contender.

If Lowe departs, Pittsburgh will receive draft-pick compensation because of the qualifying offer. That's better than nothing, but it isn't remotely equivalent to replacing a 35-homer second baseman who also emerged as one of the clubhouse's most respected leaders. And watching him leave for the same organization that previously acquired Bednar would only add insult to injury.

The Yankees aren't obligated to accommodate Pittsburgh's financial limitations. Lowe isn't obligated to accept a hometown discount. And Cherington certainly isn't entitled to another productive season from a player simply because both sides enjoyed their first year together.

If the Pirates genuinely consider Lowe a priority, they need to make him an offer that reflects it. Otherwise, all those public declarations about wanting him back will sound painfully familiar when he's hitting home runs in someone else's uniform.

Add us as a preferred source on Google