Pirates 2024 Draft: Grading first-round pick with legitimate concerns for future

In selecting Konnor Griffin at No. 9 overall, the Pittsburgh Pirates may have gotten the "steal" of the 2024 MLB Draft – in more ways than one.

Griffin, a shortstop out of Jackson Prep (Mississippi), was the 2024 Gatorade National Player of the Year and the consensus top prep position player in this year's draft. In his final high school season, he hit .559 with 13 doubles, four triples, nine home runs, 39 RBI, 85 stolen bases, a .690 on-base percentage, and a .966 slugging percentage in 43 games. He also had a 10-0 record as a pitcher with a 0.72 ERA and 102 strikeouts in 67 innings.

But perhaps Griffin's most impressive tool this season was his baserunning. He stole 85 bases in 43 games – yes, nearly two per contest. Just ... wow.

At 6'4" and 210 pounds (and just 18 years old!), Griffin certainly has the size to take long strides around the base paths. But his blinding speed isn't the only reason for his staggering number of stolen bases – he also shows remarkable baserunning instincts for a high school player.

In addition to his speed, Griffin also boasts a rocket for an arm, tons of raw power and above-average defensive ability. He may have the highest upside of any player in this year's draft class. But there's just one thing that gives us pause.

Grading the Pirates' pick of Konnor Griffin at No. 9 overall: A-

Admittedly, giving this grade to the top-ranked prep position player in this year's draft may seem harsh, but here's the thing: many scouts feel that hitting for average is Griffin's weakest tool. And that's the one tool that the Pirates desperately need the most in the organization.

Yes, Griffin just turned 18 in April. He can still develop. But historically, the Pirates aren't great at developing hitters. Just ask their 27th-ranked lineup this year, which has a team batting average of .231 and just one player hitting above .250.

Griffin's hit tool is a legitimate question mark – and one we may not have a clear answer on until he gets to full-season pro ball. Still, his power, arm and defensive utility (he can play shortstop or outfield) should make him a valuable prospect in the Pirates organization. Pirates fans should be thrilled, but also remain realistic.

More Pirates content from Rum Bunter