Skip to main content

Brandon Lowe’s Silver Slugger win ends embarrassing Pirates drought under Ben Cherington

Now, can Pittsburgh convince him to stay?
ByEmma Lingan
MLB: JUL 28 Diamondbacks at Pirates
MLB: JUL 28 Diamondbacks at Pirates | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

Brandon Lowe needed just one season with the Pittsburgh Pirates to accomplish something the organization hadn't managed in more than a decade. And while his latest achievement deserves to be celebrated, it also serves as a rather embarrassing indictment of the front office that brought him to Pittsburgh.

Lowe was named the 2026 National League Silver Slugger Award winner at second base Tuesday, beating out Milwaukee Brewers standout Brice Turang for the honor. It's the first Silver Slugger of Lowe's career and the first by a Pirates player since Andrew McCutchen won his fourth consecutive award in 2015.

Lowe is the first Pirates player to win a Silver Slugger in the Ben Cherington era, which began in 2019. In fact, Pittsburgh entered this awards cycle as the only team in Major League Baseball that hadn't produced a Silver Slugger winner since 2021.

The drought is finally over, but its conclusion raises a rather uncomfortable question: Why did it take acquiring a veteran with just one year of contractual control for Cherington to finally bring an award-winning hitter to Pittsburgh?

Brandon Lowe's Silver Slugger win exposes Pirates' biggest roster-building failure under Ben Cherington

To Lowe's credit, he earned every bit of this recognition. The 32-year-old hit .260/.331/.493 with 35 home runs, 96 RBI and an .824 OPS across 150 games in his debut season with Pittsburgh. His 33 home runs while playing second base established a franchise record, surpassing the previous mark of 23 set by Neil Walker in 2014.

Lowe also led all MLB second basemen in home runs, slugging percentage and OPS while providing the kind of legitimate middle-of-the-order production that Pirates fans had spent years begging their front office to acquire.

Cherington deserves credit for acquiring Lowe from the Tampa Bay Rays in December's three-team trade. It was arguably the most impactful offensive move of his tenure, and Lowe's production helped Pittsburgh secure its first winning season since 2018. But the fact that a player acquired for one season immediately became the organization's first Silver Slugger winner in 11 years says plenty about the offensive talent Cherington had assembled before his arrival.

Lowe arrived and immediately showed what a difference one legitimate impact bat could make. His award is a tremendous individual accomplishment. It's also a reminder of how unnecessarily long Pirates fans waited to see that caliber of offensive production.

Unfortunately for Pittsburgh, the timing of Lowe's historic achievement couldn't be much worse. He's now a free agent, and his Silver Slugger award only strengthens his case for the lucrative multiyear contract he's expected to command.

The Pirates extended Lowe a $23.15 million qualifying offer, but that was always the bare minimum they could do to protect themselves against losing him for nothing. It doesn't guarantee his return. It doesn't represent a serious long-term commitment. And it certainly doesn't prevent a more aggressive organization from offering him substantially more financial security.

As expected, Lowe declined the offer and officially became a free agent on Tuesday. Cherington has publicly expressed interest in bringing Lowe back, emphasizing the positive experience the veteran and his family had in Pittsburgh. That's encouraging, but goodwill isn't a substitute for a competitive contract offer.

There's a painful irony in the possibility that Cherington's first Silver Slugger winner could leave almost immediately after earning the award. After years of failing to construct an offense with an award-caliber hitter, the Pirates finally found one. And now there's a legitimate possibility they'll have to start searching all over again.

Lowe's Silver Slugger win is worth celebrating. He helped transform Pittsburgh's lineup, delivered one of the most productive seasons by a Pirates second baseman in franchise history and finally ended an embarrassing drought. But the award shouldn't absolve Cherington of his previous failures. If anything, it raises the standard for what comes next.

The Pirates finally have a Silver Slugger winner under Cherington. Now they need to prove they can actually keep one.

Add us as a preferred source on Google