Carmen Mlodzinski responds to issues Pirates fans had long been worried about

Carmen Mlodzinski didn’t dodge it. He didn’t deflect, didn’t hide behind clichés, didn’t pretend the pattern everyone has been watching for weeks — if not months — wasn’t real.

He met it head-on. And in doing so, he said out loud what Pittsburgh Pirates fans have been thinking for a while now.

After Sunday’s 5-0 loss to the Milwaukee Brewers, Mlodzinski sounded like a pitcher who knows exactly where things are going wrong — and is running out of time to fix them.

“I’m sick of answering those questions,” he admitted.

That wasn’t frustration with the media. It was frustration with himself. Because the question — why things unravel the second time through the order — isn’t new. It’s the same one that has followed him start after start, inning after inning, especially away from PNC Park.

After strong start for Pirates, Carmen Mlodzinksi's old demons are returning to haunt him

For three innings Sunday, Mlodzinski looked like a different pitcher entirely. He was efficient. He was in control. He allowed just one baserunner. He was putting together the kind of outing that keeps you in a rotation.

Then came the fourth — and with it, the spiral. Thirty-nine pitches. Five runs. No way out.

It’s not just that hitters are adjusting to Mlodzinski the second time through the order. It’s that once things start to go wrong, they snowball quickly. A borderline call here, a mistake pitch there, and suddenly, the inning becomes uncontainable.

The Pirates don’t question Mlodzinski’s stuff. The arm is real. The flashes are real. But starting pitching in the majors isn’t about three good innings — it’s about navigating trouble, adjusting the second time through, and stopping the bleeding when things start to tilt.

Right now, that’s the gap — and Mlodzinski knows it.

“I expect you guys to keep asking it until I fix it,” he said.

That level of accountability is encouraging to see. But accountability alone doesn’t secure a rotation spot — and the clock is ticking.

With Jared Jones beginning his rehab assignment and pushing toward a return, the competition is no longer theoretical. It’s immediate. The Pirates have options, and Mlodzinski’s profile — limited length as a starter, prior success in relief — makes him the easiest piece to move if a decision has to be made. That reality is looming, even if no one in the clubhouse is saying it outright.

Sunday’s loss wasn’t solely on Mlodzinski. The offense struck out 18 times. Joey Bart had a costly catcher’s interference in the inning that unraveled. The Pirates managed just two hits. You’re not winning many games like that.

But Mlodzinski didn’t point fingers. He pointed inward. He understands the issue. He understands the stakes. And he understands that until he fixes it, nothing else really matters.

“Want to sit here and say, ‘It’s never gonna happen again,’ but it’s probably going to happen again,” he said.

That’s the uncomfortable truth. Growth at this level isn’t linear. Fixes don’t happen overnight. But the Pirates don’t have the luxury of waiting indefinitely — not with a competitive window opening and internal options pushing from behind.

So now the question shifts. It's no longer about whether Mlodzinski knows what’s wrong — but whether he can fix it before the Pirates are forced to answer it for him.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow