Pirates fans are about to learn tough truth about rotation plans

The Pittsburgh Pirates didn’t lose Carmen Mlodzinski's last start because of some grand flaw in their roster construction or a looming rotation crisis. They lost because the Texas Rangers were better. It happens. Over 162 games, it’s supposed to happen.

But that didn’t stop the reaction.

Almost immediately after the 5-1 loss at Globe Life Field — a game in which Mlodzinski allowed five earned runs over 4 1/3 innings — the familiar refrain surfaced: he’s not a starter. He should be the odd man out. Just wait until Jared Jones comes back.

But that last part is where reality starts to drift.

Yes, Mlodzinski had his first real stumble of the season. The Rangers made him work, ran his pitch count up to 93 — the highest by a Pirates pitcher all year to that point — and punished him the third time through the order. Left-handed bats gave him trouble again.

It wasn’t clean, and it wasn’t pretty. But it also wasn’t catastrophic. It was one bad start.

The bigger issue is what fans think is coming next. There’s an assumption that once Jones returns from the injured list, everything will snap back into place — that he’ll slide right into the rotation, someone like Mlodzinski will shift out, and the Pirates will be better for it.

That’s not how this is going to work.

Pirates fans shouldn't count on Jared Jones slotting directly into rotation plans once he returns from injury

Jones hasn’t pitched in over a year following major elbow surgery. The Pirates have been deliberate — almost cautious to a fault — with every arm in this organization, and there’s no chance they abandon that approach now. When Jones returns, it won’t be as a fully stretched-out starter throwing 90-plus pitches. It will be gradual, controlled, likely in shorter stints, and possibly even out of the bullpen to build him back up.

That creates a reality Pirates fans may not be ready to accept: Mlodzinski isn’t going anywhere. Not because he’s irreplaceable, and not because Tuesday proved anything positive — but because the Pirates need innings. They need stability. And right now, even with the occasional inconsistency, Mlodzinski provides that in a way a rehabbing Jones simply can’t yet.

It’s easy to overreact in April. One rough outing, one momentum swing — like the moment Oneil Cruz’s would-be three-run homer was stolen at the wall — and suddenly everything feels bigger than it is.

But zoom out, and the picture is much clearer. The Pirates’ rotation plans aren’t about the next start. They’re about the next six months. And that means patience, whether fans like it or not.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow