It seems Pirates' Carmen Mlodzinski decision actually created a big problem

The Pittsburgh Pirates may have made the correct baseball decision with Carmen Mlodzinski, but that doesn't mean they avoided creating a problem.

When Jared Jones returned from the injured list and reclaimed his spot in the starting rotation, someone was always going to lose out. That someone became Mlodzinski, who was informed that despite a productive stretch as a starter, he would once again be moving back to the bullpen.

On paper, the decision makes sense. Jones is one of the organization's cornerstone arms. The Pirates also desperately need help in relief, making Mlodzinski's ability to throw multiple innings an attractive solution to a glaring weakness.

Unfortunately, though, these decisions don't happen on paper. And Mlodzinski's comments Thursday sounded less like a pitcher embracing a new role and more like someone trying to process another frustrating turn in a career that has repeatedly lacked stability.

The right-hander told reporters he was proud of the work he'd done as a starter. He repeatedly declined to elaborate on his future. Most notably, he revealed that he was speaking with "the organization and the people in my corner, whether that's my family or my agency, about what's next."

That isn't necessarily a trade demand, but it also certainly isn't the language of someone who is thrilled about the decision.

Pirates' Carmen Mlodzinski may have created a bigger clubhouse issue than they realized

This is now the second consecutive season that Mlodzinski has been asked to embrace a starting role, perform reasonably well in that role and then move back to the bullpen anyway. For a competitor who has spent years trying to establish himself as a Major League starter, that can feel like a moving target.

Players notice when performance appears secondary to roster construction. They notice when someone does what is asked of them and still loses their role. They notice when one of their teammates is visibly disappointed. That's why the Pirates' challenge is not only convincing Mlodzinski to accept the move, but also convincing him that there is still a long-term path for him in Pittsburgh.

The organization clearly values Mlodzinski. Manager Don Kelly has already indicated that this won't be a traditional bullpen assignment, describing him more as a high-leverage bulk reliever capable of covering multiple innings. But while the Pirates can make a strong baseball argument, whether Mlodzinski ultimately buys into it is another question.

If the frustration fades and Mlodzinski thrives in his new role, this becomes a temporary storyline. Winning has a way of making uncomfortable conversations disappear. But if he continues to feel like he's being shuffled around without a permanent home, the Pirates may find themselves dealing with something much more difficult than a rotation crunch.

They may have created the first real clubhouse tension of the Don Kelly era. And that's a far bigger problem than deciding who starts every fifth day.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow