Pirates’ Jared Jones decision shows fans wasted time worrying for weeks

For weeks, Pittsburgh Pirates fans worked themselves into a panic over a decision the team had not actually made.

The theory was simple enough: Jared Jones was nearing his return from internal brace surgery, the rotation was getting crowded and somebody had to move. From there, speculation took over. Maybe Jones himself would come back in relief. Maybe Braxton Ashcraft, despite being one of Pittsburgh’s best starters, would get pushed to the bullpen to manage his innings. Maybe the Pirates were about to overthink their way into weakening their rotation.

Instead, the actual decision was far more logical.

Jones is returning to the starting rotation Friday against the Minnesota Twins. Carmen Mlodzinski is moving to the bullpen, but not as a traditional one-inning reliever. The Pirates plan to use him as what Don Kelly called a “high-leverage bulk guy,” someone who can enter close games, cover multiple innings and potentially finish them.

In fact, Wednesday’s 10-4 loss to the Chicago Cubs showed exactly why the Pirates need that kind of arm. The game was tied through six innings before Yohan Ramirez and Justin Lawrence combined to let it unravel in the seventh. Kelly said afterward that Mlodzinski would have been perfect for that spot — and he's right.

Pirates fans were losing their minds over baseless bullpen rumors as they awaited Jared Jones' activation off the IL

This is where the fan meltdown looks especially misplaced. The concern over Ashcraft was never completely irrational; the Pirates do have to monitor his workload. He is not likely to jump carelessly into a 180- or 190-inning season, and the club would be irresponsible if it ignored that. But there is a difference between acknowledging possible innings-management tools and acting like a bullpen move is inevitable.

The Pirates can still manage Ashcraft through shorter starts, skipped turns or, potentially, a few controlled bulk-relief appearances. Nothing had been decided. Nothing was ever framed as the preferred outcome. Yet the fan reaction treated it like Ashcraft had already been demoted.

Now Jones is back, Ashcraft remains where he belongs, and Mlodzinski gives the Pirates the length with leverage that they so desperately need. The starting rotation Pittsburgh real upside, but shorter starts and innings limits are going to happen. The Pirates need a bridge that does not automatically turn a close game into a bullpen fire drill.

Mlodzinski can be that bridge. Wilber Dotel can help in a similar way. Together, they give Kelly a more creative and more sensible bullpen structure.

Jones’ return should be exciting on its own. He brings elite velocity, a wipeout slider and, by his own account, a more complete pitch mix after a year spent learning his curveball and changeup. But his return also clarified that the Pirates weren't plotting some needless rotation disaster.

Fans spent weeks worrying about a worst-case scenario. The actual move made the team better.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow