Skip to main content

Padres’ Adrian Morejon decision makes Pirates’ reported bullpen plans even more complicated

Pittsburgh needs left-handed relief help, but the market isn't doing Ben Cherington any favors.
ByEmma Lingan
National League Division Series: San Diego Padres v Milwaukee Brewers - Game One
National League Division Series: San Diego Padres v Milwaukee Brewers - Game One | Patrick McDermott/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates have made it clear that adding left-handed pitching is an offseason priority. Unfortunately for general manager Ben Cherington, the price of addressing that need may already be climbing beyond his comfort zone.

San Diego Padres reliever Adrian Morejon declined his one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer Tuesday, choosing instead to test free agency. The decision was hardly surprising given Morejon's recent dominance, but it serves as another reminder of just how expensive established late-inning relief pitching has become.

Morejon, who posted a 2.83 ERA with 107 strikeouts in 86 innings last season, is widely considered the top left-handed reliever available. He's positioned to command a lucrative multiyear deal, with MLB Trade Rumors projecting a five-year, $80 million contract.

That's almost certainly not a price the Pirates will be willing to pay, especially with significant offensive needs still unresolved. But Morejon's decision matters to Pittsburgh even if Cherington never seriously considers pursuing him. It reinforces the growing divide between what the Pirates need and what it might cost to acquire it.

Cherington said at the GM meetings last week that the Pirates are actively targeting left-handed pitching this offseason. That could include starters, relievers or both, but the bullpen presents a particularly obvious need following Gregory Soto's departure into free agency.

Mason Montgomery emerged as a legitimate late-inning weapon in 2026, while Brandon Eisert and Evan Sisk provide additional left-handed depth. Neither, however, has established himself as the kind of dependable, high-leverage complement that Soto represented — and finding another one won't necessarily be cheap.

Morejon headlines a free-agent class that also includes Alex Vesia, JoJo Romero, Steven Okert, José Alvarado and Soto himself. While that gives Cherington several options, it also means Pittsburgh will be competing against clubs with significantly greater financial flexibility.

The market has already offered a warning. The Atlanta Braves signed former Dodgers reliever Evan Phillips to a three-year, $35 million contract earlier this month, establishing an expensive early benchmark for proven bullpen arms.

Vesia figures to attract considerable interest, while Romero and Okert could present somewhat more affordable alternatives. MLB Trade Rumors projected a two-year, $13 million deal for Romero, potentially making him an attractive middle-ground option. But affordable doesn't necessarily mean inexpensive, and pursuing a lower-cost alternative comes with its own risks.

Would the Pirates be better off simply bringing back Gregory Soto?

That's the question Cherington should be asking before committing to another bullpen reclamation project.

Pittsburgh signed Soto to a one-year, $7.75 million contract last offseason, and while his performance wasn't flawless, the investment largely worked. The veteran southpaw finished 2026 with a 3.63 ERA, 79 strikeouts in 67 innings and 16 saves.

Soto certainly had his frustrating moments, particularly with his command. But the Pirates know exactly what he brings, how he fits into their bullpen and what adjustments helped him succeed.

Of course, bringing him back won't necessarily be the budget-friendly solution it was a year ago. ESPN's Kiley McDaniel projected Soto to command a three-year, $36 million contract, a substantial increase over his previous deal.

At that price, Cherington would have to think carefully about whether committing multiple seasons to a reliever entering his age-32 campaign makes sense. Still, there is something counterproductive about allowing a reasonably successful free-agent signing to walk, only to spend the following offseason searching for a comparable replacement.

The Pirates need someone who can approximate Soto's production without consuming resources better spent improving a lineup that still has significant shortcomings. And if the cost of finding that player approaches what it would take to retain Soto, Pittsburgh might be better off sticking with the reliever it already knows.

Cherington found value in the bullpen market last winter. The challenge now is repeating that success in a market that appears considerably less forgiving. With a potential lockout approaching on Dec. 2, he may not have much time to figure it out.

Add us as a preferred source on Google