The Pittsburgh Pirates protected one of their most promising prospects from the Rule 5 Draft on Tuesday. But in doing so, they may have inadvertently put his development at risk.
Pittsburgh added catcher Axiel Plaz and outfielder Mitch Jebb to its 40-man roster ahead of Tuesday's protection deadline, filling its two remaining vacancies. The decisions were understandable, particularly given Plaz's breakout 2026 season.
But with a potential MLB lockout looming on December 2, protecting Plaz could come with an unintended consequence that has nothing to do with the Rule 5 Draft itself.
If the work stoppage extends into the 2027 minor league season, Plaz could lose valuable development time simply because he's now on the 40-man roster. And considering how far he still is from actually reaching the majors, that's a risk the Pirates can't afford to overlook.
Pirates' Axiel Plaz protection creates unexpected development dilemma
Plaz, 21, emerged as one of Pittsburgh's most intriguing prospects in 2026, hitting .305 with 18 home runs, 74 RBI and a .902 OPS across 94 games at High-A Greensboro. He also reduced his strikeout rate to a career-low 17.2%, demonstrating significant offensive growth. MLB Pipeline now ranks him as the Pirates' No. 7 prospect.
Axiel Plaz HOMER!
— Greensboro Grasshoppers (@GSOHoppers) July 2, 2026
Hoppers: 1 | Hot Rods: 1 pic.twitter.com/gWg4PFnOB3
But here's the problem: Plaz has yet to play a single game above High-A. He's still developing as a catcher, and his next challenge will presumably be proving his offensive improvements translate against more advanced pitching at Double-A Altoona. A prolonged lockout could interfere with that progression.
During the previous MLB lockout in 2021-22, players on 40-man rosters were prohibited from participating in affiliated minor league spring training and games until the work stoppage ended. Meanwhile, prospects outside the 40-man roster continued developing without those restrictions. If similar restrictions apply during another prolonged shutdown, Plaz could be sidelined while other Pirates prospects continue preparing for and playing the 2027 season.
Of course, Cherington faced a difficult choice. Leaving Plaz unprotected would have exposed him to the Rule 5 Draft, currently scheduled for December 9. Even though a lockout could cancel the draft altogether, gambling on that outcome would have carried its own risks.
And unlike Jebb, who has already reached Triple-A, Plaz is likely still multiple developmental steps away from Pittsburgh. Protecting him was arguably the right decision. But that doesn't mean it's without consequences.
If the lockout ends before spring training, the concern could prove irrelevant. If negotiations drag into April or beyond, however, Pittsburgh could find itself watching one of its most promising young hitters lose meaningful repetitions at a crucial stage of his development.
The Pirates protected Plaz from losing his place in the organization. Now they have to hope they haven't cost him valuable time getting to the majors.
