The Pittsburgh Pirates have an unusual opportunity to take advantage of Major League Baseball's impending labor uncertainty. But if general manager Ben Cherington gets too clever, it could end up costing the organization some of its most intriguing young talent.
Tuesday marks MLB's deadline for teams to add Rule 5-eligible prospects to their 40-man rosters. Players left unprotected can be selected by another organization during the Major League phase of the Rule 5 Draft, currently scheduled for Dec. 9.
Except there's a significant possibility that draft never happens.
With MLB's collective bargaining agreement set to expire Dec. 1, an owners' lockout is widely anticipated. That would freeze major league transactions, potentially forcing the league to postpone or cancel the Major League portion of the Rule 5 Draft altogether.
There's even recent precedent. The 2021 Major League Rule 5 Draft was ultimately canceled because of the previous lockout, despite teams having already made their roster-protection decisions. Cherington could reasonably gamble on history repeating itself, leaving more prospects unprotected than he otherwise would to preserve valuable 40-man roster flexibility.
The other wrinkle is that players on 40-man rosters would be subject to the lockout, potentially interrupting their minor league development. Leaving younger prospects off the roster could allow them to continue playing and working with their organizations during a prolonged stoppage.
But there's an obvious downside. If the Major League Rule 5 Draft proceeds, the Pirates could expose legitimate prospects to other organizations simply because they bet on a cancellation that never materialized.
Pirates' Rule 5-eligible prospects and their chances of being protected
According to MLB Pipeline, six of Pittsburgh's current top-30 prospects require protection ahead of Tuesday's deadline. Several additional players, including Mitch Jebb and Derek Diamond, also warrant serious consideration. Here's how their chances stack up, with the likelihood they will be protected.
Axiel Plaz, C/1B (No. 7 prospect) — High
Plaz might be Pittsburgh's most obvious protection candidate. The 21-year-old hit .305 with 18 home runs in 94 games at High-A Greensboro, establishing himself as one of the organization's biggest breakout prospects in 2026.
His offensive upside and catching ability make him too valuable to expose unnecessarily. Although he's yet to reach Double-A, leaving Pittsburgh's seventh-ranked prospect vulnerable would be an enormous gamble.
Axiel Plaz dingers TWICE in one game ‼️ pic.twitter.com/h5h7A4KJ5C
— Young Bucs (@YoungBucsPIT) August 12, 2026
Yordany De Los Santos, INF (No. 14) — Moderate to high
De Los Santos produced 19 home runs and 45 stolen bases in 2026, showcasing the combination of power and athleticism that makes him an intriguing long-term infield option.
His strikeout concerns and lack of upper-minors experience could discourage teams from using a Rule 5 selection on him. Still, his upside makes him a serious protection candidate.
Termarr Johnson, 2B (No. 19) — Low
Johnson's situation is complicated by his season-ending ACL and LCL injuries. The former fourth-overall pick struggled to a .199/.336/.319 slash line at Triple-A Indianapolis before getting hurt.
Protecting him would demonstrate continued faith in his long-term potential, but another team would have to be willing to navigate his recovery and eventual major league roster requirements. Pittsburgh could view him as a relatively safe gamble to leave exposed, especially if a lockout threatens his rehabilitation and development schedule.
Lonnie White Jr., OF (No. 25) — Moderate to high
White has already been eligible for the Rule 5 Draft, but his 2026 performance could change the equation. He hit 26 home runs, stole 21 bases and posted a .270/.376/.520 slash line.
His combination of power, athleticism and Double-A experience could attract another organization. After years of waiting for White to put everything together, losing him now would be especially frustrating.
Tony Blanco Jr., 1B (No. 27) — Moderate
Blanco's impressive raw power makes him an intriguing candidate, particularly after another productive season in the lower minors. But his strikeout tendencies and limited defensive versatility could make it difficult for another team to carry him on its major league roster for an entire season.
That makes him one of the more tempting players to leave unprotected, although the Pirates would still be risking a potentially impactful power bat.
MY GOODNESS 😱@Pirates prospect Tony Blanco Jr. just sent this grand slam to space! #SpringBreakout pic.twitter.com/e3pA59Ktfl
— MLB (@MLB) March 21, 2026
Jhonny Severino, INF/OF (No. 28) — Moderate to high
Severino might present one of Pittsburgh's most uncomfortable decisions after hitting 31 home runs with 95 RBI and 16 stolen bases at Greensboro.
The 22-year-old still needs to prove himself against upper-level pitching, and his on-base percentage leaves room for improvement. However, his offensive breakout gives rival organizations a compelling reason to consider taking a chance on him.
Mitch Jebb, OF — Moderate to high
Jebb reached Triple-A in 2026 and finished the season with a .274/.352/.432 slash line, eight home runs and 14 stolen bases across the minors.
His speed, contact skills and ability to contribute at multiple positions could make him an attractive Rule 5 target. Unlike some of Pittsburgh's younger prospects, Jebb isn't nearly as far removed from a potential major league role.
Derek Diamond, RHP — High
Diamond could be especially vulnerable if left unprotected. The 25-year-old posted a 2.48 ERA with 57 strikeouts across 58 innings in 2026, making a strong case for a future bullpen opportunity.
Relievers are often easier for teams to carry under Rule 5 roster restrictions than position players who need regular developmental at-bats. That makes Diamond's strong season and upper-minors experience particularly relevant.
The Pirates also have other eligible players throughout their system, including pitchers Jaden Woods, Carlson Reed and Landon Tomkins, along with previously eligible prospects such as Anthony Solometo and Keiner Delgado. Those players appear less likely to earn protection, although a team looking for pitching depth could still find an intriguing option among Pittsburgh's unprotected arms.
Ben Cherington can't afford to bank on history repeating itself with the Rule 5 Draft
The biggest problem with exploiting this potential loophole is that nobody can guarantee the outcome. A lockout could result in the Major League Rule 5 Draft being canceled, as it was in 2021. But it could also be postponed, or labor circumstances could change enough for the draft to proceed.
For an organization like Pittsburgh, which has spent years emphasizing the importance of building sustainable success through its farm system, unnecessarily exposing multiple promising players would be difficult to justify.
There is a reasonable middle ground. Cherington can prioritize prospects with legitimate major league appeal, particularly Plaz, Diamond and some of the system's emerging power hitters, while taking calculated risks on players whose development timelines make them less likely Rule 5 selections.
The Pirates have already demonstrated how difficult it can be to turn prospect potential into consistent major league production. They shouldn't make that process even harder by losing valuable organizational talent over a roster-management gamble.
The lockout might give Cherington an opportunity to preserve roster flexibility without sacrificing a single prospect. But if he guesses wrong, the cost could be far greater than the 40-man spots he was trying to save. For the Pirates, that's a loophole worth considering — not one worth trusting blindly.
