Of all the prospects the Pittsburgh Pirates left exposed to the Rule 5 Draft, Termarr Johnson is understandably generating the most attention. After all, it's not every day that a team leaves a former No. 4 overall pick unprotected just four years after drafting him.
But Johnson's name recognition is doing a lot of heavy lifting in this conversation. His exclusion from Pittsburgh's 40-man roster wasn't nearly as surprising as his draft pedigree might suggest, and he's probably not the player the Pirates should be most worried about losing.
The Pirates protected catcher Axiel Plaz and outfielder Mitch Jebb ahead of Tuesday's deadline, filling their remaining two 40-man roster spots. In doing so, they left several prospects available for a potential Rule 5 Draft on Dec. 9, including a pair of Triple-A pitchers who could realistically contribute to another team's major league bullpen next season.
Johnson, meanwhile, represents a considerably different situation. The 22-year-old hit just .199/.336/.319 with eight home runs and 101 strikeouts in 96 games at Triple-A Indianapolis in 2026. His season ended in August after he tore the ACL and LCL in his left knee, further complicating an already disappointing development trajectory.
Even without the injury, Johnson hasn't demonstrated that he's ready to handle major league pitching. A rebuilding team could theoretically select him and stash him on the injured list during his recovery, but that would require a substantial commitment to a player whose production has consistently fallen short of expectations.
Keeping Johnson off the roster also allows Pittsburgh to maintain communication with him throughout his rehabilitation if the anticipated lockout begins in December. It's a defensible decision, even if it's an uncomfortable reminder of how far his prospect stock has fallen.
Derek Diamond and Brandon Neeck are exactly the kind of pitchers teams target in the Rule 5 Draft
The Pirates' decision to leave Derek Diamond and Brandon Neeck exposed to the Rule 5 Draft is much harder to justify.
Diamond might be Pittsburgh's most obvious selection risk. The 25-year-old right-hander was named the organization's Kent Tekulve Reliever of the Year after posting a 2.48 ERA, 57 strikeouts and a 1.02 WHIP across 58 innings in 2026.
He was particularly impressive with his command, walking just 3.9% of opposing hitters. At Triple-A Indianapolis, Diamond recorded a 3.14 ERA over 29 appearances, and his ability to work multiple innings makes him an especially attractive bullpen candidate.
His mid-90s fastball and assortment of breaking pitches give him a realistic path to a major league relief role. There are questions about his strikeout upside and injury history, but those concerns hardly eliminate him from consideration. Baseball America has already identified Diamond among its potential Rule 5 selections.
Derek Diamond is your Kent Tekulve Reliever of the Year‼️😮💨 pic.twitter.com/bQUdR1XkPF
— Young Bucs (@YoungBucsPIT) October 21, 2026
Neeck presents a different but similarly compelling case. The left-hander compiled a 2.33 ERA with 101 strikeouts in 69 2/3 innings between Double-A Altoona and Indianapolis. At Triple-A alone, he struck out 59 batters in 42 2/3 innings while posting a 2.95 ERA.
Neeck's biggest weakness is his command. He issued 47 walks across the two levels, including 31 at Indianapolis. Still, left-handed relievers capable of missing bats are valuable, and Neeck's strikeout numbers could be enough to attract a team willing to tolerate some growing pains.
Neither pitcher is a guaranteed major league contributor, but that's precisely why the Rule 5 Draft exists. Teams can take calculated chances on players who might be ready for an opportunity their original organization hasn't provided.
It's worth noting that the anticipated MLB lockout could prevent the Rule 5 Draft from happening altogether, just as it did during the previous work stoppage. That uncertainty may have influenced Pittsburgh's decision not to clear additional roster spots beyond the two already available.
But if the draft proceeds, Diamond and Neeck are the kinds of relatively advanced relievers another organization could reasonably carry on its major league roster. Under Rule 5 rules, selecting teams must keep their picks on the active roster for the required portion of the season or risk having to offer them back.
The Pirates have spent considerable time and resources trying to stabilize their bullpen. Losing inexpensive, nearly major league-ready pitching depth for minimal compensation would be an avoidable setback. Johnson's exclusion might be the most eye-catching decision Pittsburgh made Tuesday, but it isn't necessarily the most consequential.
If the Pirates lose Diamond or Neeck next month, the decision to leave them unprotected could look much worse than anything involving their former first-round pick.
