The Pittsburgh Pirates have an intriguing decision to make ahead of Friday's non-tender deadline, and it involves considerably more than Endy Rodríguez's projected salary for 2027.
Rodríguez is among Pittsburgh's arbitration-eligible players, with MLB Trade Rumors projecting him to earn approximately $1.2 million next season. Given his extensive injury history and uncertain recovery timeline, the Pirates could theoretically non-tender the 26-year-old catcher and attempt to bring him back on a minor league contract.
But with Major League Baseball potentially headed toward a lockout on December 2 after the current collective bargaining agreement expires, what initially looks like a clever roster-management maneuver comes with a significant complication.
The Pirates could preserve access to Rodríguez throughout his rehabilitation by keeping him off their 40-man roster. But to accomplish that, they'd first have to risk losing him altogether.
MLB lockout creates unusual incentive for Pirates to consider Endy Rodríguez non-tender
Rodríguez underwent season-ending surgery to repair the labrum in his left hip in August, with an expected recovery timeline of seven to nine months before he can resume baseball activities. That would likely keep him sidelined into the early portion of the 2027 season.
It's another frustrating setback for a player who has already undergone Tommy John surgery, a flexor tendon repair and a separate procedure involving his ulnar nerve.
Under normal circumstances, those injuries would simply complicate the Pirates' decision about whether to guarantee Rodríguez another major league contract. This offseason, however, the impending lockout adds another consideration.
In the event of a lockout, players on 40-man rosters would be prohibited from communicating with their organizations or using team facilities for rehabilitation, as was the case during the 2021-22 work stoppage. Players on minor league contracts who aren't on 40-man rosters, meanwhile, would generally remain eligible to work with team personnel and continue their rehabilitation programs.
For Rodríguez, whose recovery is expected to extend well into 2027, that distinction could be particularly important. Non-tendering him and successfully re-signing him to a minor league deal before the lockout would allow Pittsburgh to maintain communication with him, oversee his recovery and avoid dedicating a 40-man roster spot to a player who won't be ready for Opening Day.
The biggest problem with this approach, of course, is that non-tendering Rodríguez would immediately make him a free agent. Pittsburgh wouldn't have exclusive negotiating rights, and Rodríguez would have no obligation to accept a minor league contract simply because the Pirates wanted to retain him.
Another organization could offer him a major league deal, a clearer path to playing time or a more attractive opportunity once he's healthy. And despite his injury history, Rodríguez has demonstrated enough upside to attract that kind of interest.
In 45 games during the 2026 season, he hit .267/.373/.467 with seven home runs and an .840 OPS. At one point, he appeared capable of overtaking Henry Davis as Pittsburgh's primary catcher before injuries interrupted his progress. Those numbers aren't enough to erase legitimate durability concerns, but they certainly suggest Rodríguez remains a potentially valuable contributor when healthy.
Endy Rodríguez gives the @Pirates insurance in the 9th with a 3-run blast 🏴☠️ pic.twitter.com/OPQdnKJA2v
— MLB (@MLB) June 30, 2026
Pittsburgh could certainly benefit from additional roster flexibility, particularly after protecting Axiel Plaz and Mitch Jebb ahead of the Rule 5 deadline. But the potential financial savings from replacing Rodríguez's major league deal with a minor league contract would be modest compared to the possibility of losing a talented, controllable catcher.
The Pirates have invested years in Rodríguez's development, and his performance in 2026 offered encouraging evidence that he could still become an important part of their future. Sacrificing their contractual control over him just to preserve access during a potential lockout would be an awfully expensive gamble for such limited financial savings.
Ben Cherington's safest decision is probably the simplest one: tender Rodríguez a contract, retain his rights and figure out the rehabilitation complications from there.
