Pirates finally demote struggling reliever in much-needed bullpen shakeup

The Pittsburgh Pirates finally made the move that had been building for weeks — and frankly, one they could no longer afford to delay.

Optioning José Urquidy to Triple-A Indianapolis is more than a routine roster shuffle. It's an overdue acknowledgment that early-season patience has its limits, especially for a bullpen already walking a tightrope.

Urquidy was brought in on a modest one-year deal with the idea that he could stabilize innings, whether as rotation depth or a long reliever. Instead, his time in Pittsburgh quickly became a liability. An 8.53 ERA and a 2.68 WHIP across just over six innings tells the story plainly — too many baserunners, too little margin for error. In a bullpen that’s already struggled to find consistency, those outings didn’t just hurt; they compounded existing issues.

This isn’t about one bad appearance. It’s about a pattern. And for a team trying to balance development with contention — while also managing a young rotation carefully — there’s no room for uncertainty in bulk innings.

Pirates option veteran José Urquidy, recall rookie Cam Sanders in corresponding bullpen moves

Enter Cam Sanders, a 29-year-old rookie who represents both a gamble and a necessity. On paper, Sanders isn’t a sure thing. His brief major league debut last year (8.10 ERA) didn’t inspire confidence, and his early Triple-A numbers this season — while showing some strikeout ability — come with command concerns.

But here’s the key difference: Sanders offers volatility with upside. Urquidy, at this stage, was offering volatility without it.

The Pirates don’t need perfection from the back end of their bullpen right now. They need arms that can miss bats, limit damage, and, above all, give the coaching staff something to build on. Sanders, for all his question marks, at least fits that mold better than what Urquidy had shown.

More importantly, this move signals a shift in approach. For much of the early season, the Pirates leaned on experience, hoping veterans would steady the ship. Instead, it’s been the younger, higher-octane arms — even in limited samples — that have provided glimpses of what this bullpen could become. Leaning into that identity isn’t just logical; it’s necessary.

There’s still plenty to sort out. One roster move won’t fix a bullpen that’s been inconsistent through the first few weeks. But it’s a start — a clear message that performance, not pedigree, will dictate roles. And for a team trying to prove it’s turning a corner, that message matters just as much as the move itself.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow