Skip to main content

Pirates' first offseason addition could be gone before Thanksgiving

Don't get too comfortable.
ByEmma Lingan
MLB: MAY 23 Guardians at Tigers
MLB: MAY 23 Guardians at Tigers | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates' first roster addition of the offseason might not even make it to the end of November.

On November 2, Pittsburgh claimed outfielder Akil Baddoo off waivers from the Milwaukee Brewers, taking a low-risk flier on a former promising young player who could potentially provide some much-needed outfield depth in 2027.

Less than three weeks later, Baddoo could already be on his way out.

According to a November 13 report from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the Pirates are expected to tender contracts to most, if not all, of their 11 arbitration-eligible players ahead of Friday's deadline. The one possible exception is Baddoo, who is projected to earn $1.3 million through arbitration, according to MLB Trade Rumors.

It's a relatively insignificant amount of money by Major League standards, even for the notoriously budget-conscious Pirates. But Baddoo's potential departure would have less to do with his projected salary than the roster flexibility Pittsburgh would sacrifice by keeping him.

Akil Baddoo's roster limitations could make him an early Pirates casualty

Baddoo initially looked like a worthwhile gamble for general manager Ben Cherington. The 28-year-old once appeared to have a promising future with the Detroit Tigers, posting a .766 OPS with 13 home runs and 18 stolen bases during his rookie season in 2021.

He hasn't replicated that production consistently since, and injuries have complicated his development. Still, he showed some encouraging signs in Milwaukee's minor league system in 2026, hitting .252/.342/.469 with 11 home runs and seven stolen bases while posting a 113 wRC+ in Triple-A. Those numbers made him an intriguing depth addition for a Pirates team that still has questions to answer about its outfield heading into next season.

Unfortunately for Baddoo, he's out of minor league options. That means Pittsburgh can't simply stash him at Triple-A Indianapolis without first exposing him to waivers. If the Pirates tender him a contract, they'll essentially be betting that he can earn a spot on their Opening Day roster or that they'll be comfortable risking losing him later. That's a considerably bigger commitment than the original waiver claim suggested.

Pittsburgh's outfield picture is already becoming crowded, too. The Pirates recently signed former Houston Astros outfielder Chas McCormick to a minor league contract with a spring training invitation. They also protected prospect Mitch Jebb from the Rule 5 Draft by adding him to the 40-man roster, giving the organization another potential option down the road.

Meanwhile, younger players such as Esmerlyn Valdez and Rafael Flores Jr. will also be competing for significant opportunities next season. None of those developments automatically makes Baddoo expendable. But they certainly complicate his path to meaningful playing time.

Pirates' potential Baddoo reversal exposes problem with Cherington's roster strategy

Taking chances on players with some demonstrated major league upside is a perfectly reasonable way to build organizational depth, particularly for a team operating with Pittsburgh's financial limitations. But there's a difference between accumulating potential contributors and actually having room for them.

Cherington has emphasized the importance of maintaining roster flexibility throughout the offseason. Baddoo's situation illustrates how quickly that flexibility can disappear when a player doesn't have minor league options remaining.

If Pittsburgh believes Baddoo can legitimately contribute to its 2027 major league roster, $1.3 million is hardly an unreasonable investment. If the organization views him primarily as Triple-A insurance, however, keeping him makes considerably less sense.

The Pirates could also attempt to bring him back on a minor league deal if they decide not to tender him a contract, although he'd be free to explore opportunities elsewhere.

Ultimately, whether Baddoo stays or goes won't define Pittsburgh's offseason. But it would be a rather telling development if Cherington's first acquisition didn't survive the first major roster deadline.

For a team that needs genuine upgrades rather than another collection of interchangeable depth pieces, the more important question is whether the next addition will have a clearer path to making an impact.

Add us as a preferred source on Google