Pirates insider predicts Brandon Lowe heartbreak fans are already fearing

Pittsburgh Pirates fans have known for months that Brandon Lowe’s looming free agency could end painfully. Now, one prominent insider is predicting exactly that.

Buried in an offseason predictions column, Pirates insider Jason Mackey offered a forecast that would qualify as one of the most painful possible outcomes of Pittsburgh’s winter:

“Sadly, Lowe signs elsewhere. Would love, love, love to be wrong. But Lowe had a stellar season at a position where power can be at a premium. There’ll be a team — probably multiple — willing to tack on a fourth year and pay a lot for Lowe’s services. So much so that it might not make sense for the Pirates. And once more, with emphasis: Let’s hope this is way off.”

That is precisely the scenario Pirates fans have been fearing since it became apparent just how valuable Lowe would be to this team. And the most frustrating part is that none of Mackey’s reasoning is difficult to understand.

Lowe did exactly what Pittsburgh needed him to do in 2026. He provided power with more than 30 home runs and became one of the primary drivers behind an offense that finally took a meaningful step forward.

He also did it while playing a premium offensive position at second base, making his production considerably more difficult to replace than simply finding another hitter capable of reaching 20-plus home runs. That is why Lowe’s free agency was always going to get uncomfortable.

Brandon Lowe may have priced himself beyond Pirates' comfort zone

The Pirates can talk all they want about wanting Lowe back. General manager Ben Cherington has already praised what he brought both on the field and inside the clubhouse. But wanting him back and being willing to outbid the rest of the market are very different things.

Mackey’s prediction gets to the heart of the problem: If another team is willing to guarantee Lowe four years, will the Pirates match it? History provides plenty of reason for skepticism.

Pittsburgh has traditionally been reluctant to make lengthy, expensive commitments in free agency, particularly to players entering their 30s. Lowe will turn 33 next July, meaning a four-year contract would carry him through his age-36 season.

There are perfectly legitimate baseball reasons for being cautious with contracts like that. But there is also a point where excessive caution becomes its own risk.

The Pirates spent years searching for exactly the sort of hitter Lowe became for them. They finally found a proven power bat who fit their lineup, performed in Pittsburgh and earned the respect of a young clubhouse. Allowing him to leave because another team offered one additional guaranteed season would merely restart the same search, and there's no guarantee the replacement would be cheaper.

Pirates can't afford another offseason built around replacing production they already had

The Pirates already know Lowe works. They know what his left-handed power looks like at PNC Park. They know how he fits alongside Oneil Cruz, Konnor Griffin, Rafael Flores Jr. and the rest of a lineup the organization hopes can keep improving in 2027. They know what Lowe brings behind the scenes, too, based on the repeated endorsements he received from teammates down the stretch.

Jared Jones, Griffin and Ryan O’Hearn were among the Pirates who publicly made their feelings about Lowe's future clear. They want him back. Fans do, too. Yet Pittsburgh could still wind up watching another organization decide Lowe is worth the contract the Pirates weren't willing to offer.

And then what? The Pirates would suddenly need to replace one of their best hitters at the same time they're supposed to be adding more offense around their existing core. That's moving sideways during an offseason when Pittsburgh desperately needs to move forward.

The Pirates finished 82-80 in 2026, ending their streak of losing seasons but still missing the postseason. The goal for 2027 cannot simply be maintaining that roster and hoping internal improvement creates another few wins.

They need additions. Losing Lowe would create a subtraction before Cherington even begins addressing the roster's other weaknesses.

That's why the phrase “it might not make sense for the Pirates” deserves scrutiny if Mackey's prediction becomes reality. Maybe four years ultimately does carry significant risk. Maybe Lowe's market reaches a number Pittsburgh reasonably decides it cannot justify.

But if the difference between retaining one of the franchise's most important hitters and losing him is simply stretching beyond the organization's usual comfort zone, the Pirates need to remember what happened the last time they remained too comfortable.

Seven years of rebuilding eventually produced an 82-win team. Now comes the expensive part. Keeping good players tends to cost money. Building a playoff roster requires accepting some contractual risk. And when a player performs as well as Lowe did, the rest of baseball notices.

Pirates fans already knew that. Mackey’s prediction simply gave their biggest offseason fear a voice.

Now Pittsburgh has the opportunity to make sure he’s wrong.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow